TheBookSwarm
Ask Question

open Discussion: First-Person vs. Third-Person narrative?

open Discussion:

First-Person vs. Third-Person narrative?

Givemore #questionnaire

7
Reply
Related
First Person or Third Person?
30 answers
Do you like books be told in first-person or third-person? I find books told by multiple characters in first-person confusing.
8 answers
Do you prefer to read books written in first or third person? ?
56 answers
Do you prefer 1st person POV or third person narrator?
9 answers
Am I the only person who hasn’t read Gone Girl? Just about to open it. Will I enjoy it?
49 answers
The Book a person reads defines the person. Comment a book which defines you.
15 answers
Describe the book you are reading with first person pronouns! GO!
179 answers
What’s the best compliment a bookish person can get :)
34 answers
Hey all, I’m looking for thriller recs written in first person. Crime thrillers mostly, but any thriller would be helpful. Thanks.
11 answers
Seeing someone reading a book you love is seeing a book recommending a person.
20 answers

48 Answers

Michelle

Third with different POVs.

3
Reply
Kan

Definitely prefer third person.

0
Reply
Julieanne

Since that person was so rude, third person.

0
Reply
Amy

Generally third person, with a few notable exceptions (like The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-time)

0
Reply
Christina

I never really gave this any thought but now I’m wondering if there is a connection between this and the stories I didn’t like. You’ve given me something to think about.

2
Reply
Dennis

Third person

0
Reply
Mike-Stacey

First person

0
Reply
Sarah

Both. Depends on the plot or themes. Usually I like psychological crime to be in the third person but comedy and romance in the first.

1
Reply
Sallie

First person

0
Reply
Nancy

I like both. I don’t have a preference.

0
Reply
Gail

Third person.

0
Reply
Melinda

No preference.

0
Reply
Con

First if it’s a complex or unreliable narrator – otherwise third

1
Reply
Jade

Third, for writing and reading. I will not continue reading a 1st if it’s not superb.

0
Reply
Susan

Generally I prefer third. But will read either.

0
Reply
Loidang

I prefer third person narrative.

0
Reply
Andrew

3rd person narration allows for additional insight.

1
Reply
Luz

Third person

0
Reply
Hesborn

First person

0
Reply
Megan

Third person

0
Reply
Amber

Really dislike first person. Find it hard to get into the story

1
Reply
Elizma

Both

0
Reply
Carol

Both….

0
Reply
Norris

Both

0
Reply
Argel

Third

0
Reply
Amruta

Third Person

0
Reply
Adrian

Both, though I generally write in First-Person

0
Reply
Courtney

i want to learn how to write in first person. 🙁

0
Reply
Jill

Third

0
Reply
A.J.

Anything but 2nd person ?

0
Reply
Sarah

Quite like it for short stories but my head would spin reading a novel in second person narrative ?

1
Martha

third person

0
Reply
Paula

First! But I also like third.

0
Reply
Joe

Which first and which third? There are several POVs resident within each. First person gives several options, and they all read quite differently: interior monologue, stream of consciousness, memoir, subjective narration (with additional options of central vs. peripheral narration) and objective autobiography. Third person offers omniscient–which I write in, using a fictional narrator who tells the story without ever injecting himself into it–as well as third person limited, framed narrative (switching from first to third; sort of omniscient on steroids–Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein and Patrick Rothfuss’s The Name of the Wind are two well-known books written in framed narrative), and objective/detached, which I hate reading with the fire of a thousand suns. Objective is what you get when someone who has only watched TV or movies decides to write a book, and they only describe the actions. I’ll read any of them (except for detached third), as long as the author shows me that they know which one they’re doing and they stick to it–or that they know when and why to switch. I loved The Art of Racing in the Rain because the author used first-person central subjective when the dog was talking about himself, and a first-person subjective peripheral voice when the dog was observing his family. It’s really a master class in first-person voice and belongs on every author’s–or aspiring author’s–bookshelf. When an author starts weaving between first-person POVs or third-person POVs, I usually reach for the EJECT handle. Thank God for the Look Inside feature on Amazon, because an author who doesn’t understand voice past “first” and “third” will usually screw it up in the first two or three pages. Individual mileage may vary.

1
Reply
GivemoreQuestion author

thank you for bringing up the framed narrative – i read the Heart of Darkness for my English Communication Science BA (Uncompleted Degree, i switched to Accounting by the way)

0
Hannah

Either one ??‍♀️

0
Reply
Grace

Third

0
Reply
Devin

I prefer 3rd person but will read both. I do find it challenging to get into 1st person POV for some reason.

0
Reply
S

Why might be in my comment below?‍♀️

1
Devin

That makes sense! When my fiction is in 1st I just hate it usually (seeing the word “I” over and over irks me). I recently read Into the Wild and his use of “I” didn’t bother me at all.

0
Melody

Any

0
Reply
Dwayne

I can become so captivated that I forget who’s telling the story.

1
Reply
S

For fiction 3rd Person Limited POV (not omniscient) is the publisher’s preference, and mine, for anything that isn’t a memoir. There are millennias of publishing research proving it’s the superior storytelling form. However, to distinguish a memoir in its genre 1st person makes the best narrative fit.

1st person is easiest to write for fiction and considered a beginner POV. Readers only get the story from a singular point of view ever. The reader never gets another characters take on the protagonist’s or antihero’s behavior. But with 3rd limited you view the same behaviors through different people’s eyes in different scenes and feel more connected to a variety of characters and their internal conflicts. 3rdP omniscient however is usually a mess of jumping from one person’s head to the next and feeling confused. 3rdP Limited creates the richest, cleanest and most easily relatable reading experience.

0
Reply
Erin

Both but sometimes first person is written TOO much like as if they were in a normal conversation. Too many filler words like “like” is when I don’t like first person

0
Reply
Michelle

Just tell me the story.

1
Reply
Harriet

For me it depends on the writing style.

0
Reply
Jamie

I prefer 3rd. I feel like I’m reading a true story when reading first but I still will read them. Just prefer 3rd.

0
Reply
Joshua

It would be interesting if there was a first-person narrative book but the person was not the main character so it read like a third-person narrative book.

0
Reply
Leave a Answer Cancel

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Loading Please wait
Log in
Register
Categories
  • get the book
  • questionnaire
  • recommend
  • review
Genres
animal art biography business chick lit classics comics contemporary cookbooks crime detective fantasy fiction gay and lesbian graphic novel historical fiction history horror humor and comedy kids languages manga memoir music mystery nonfiction novel paranormal philosophy poetry psychology religies religion romance scary science science fiction self help spirituality sports suspense thriller travel young adult young adults
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions

2019 © TheBookSwarm