TheBookSwarm
Ask Question

Just wondering if I’m alone in disliking “Christmas themed” books? Am I a Grinch?

Just wondering if I’m alone in disliking “Christmas themed” books? Am I a Grinch?

Manda #review

55
Reply

98 Answers

Maggie

Nope. Hate them 🙂 Except that kids book Dean Koontz did years ago. That was wicked 🙂

1
Reply
Keri

Nope, I never read them. I just can’t get into them.

2
Reply
Christy

Never had either

1
Reply
Jonathon

Nope

1
Reply
Christy

But I love movies

3
Reply
Val

No

1
Reply
Leslie

No.

1
Reply
MandaQuestion author

I’m hearing a lot of “no’s”, which heartens me! But a few more details would be nice LOL. I mean, I don’t hate Christmas, per se, but I sure could do without it.

1
Reply
Nicola

I’m with you there I don’t hate Christmas but I could do without it… I worked retail for 16 years and Christmas started in August for me to I’m tired of it haha… I like Christmas Day though feels nice to be with all the fam-a-lam ???

2
MandaQuestion author

It’s pretty much a relief when the Christmas season is finished, right??

0
Nicola

Definitely… As soon as Christmas Day is over it’s like ‘whew that was enough for one year’ ???… Although the way the time is going soon it will be Christmas all the bloody time lol

1
MandaQuestion author

LOL, I get that! Time passes all too quickly as one gets older! That Stephen King story of My Pretty Pony says it all ?

0
Nicola

It does haha ??? … ???

1
Tracey

I love Christmas. My chronically ill daughter is actually singing at a nursing home today. Handing out little gifts, baked cookies, etc. I love the extra time with family. I love all of it.

2
Nicola

That sounds really cool… Hope it all went okay and you had a brilliant time ????

0
Nicola

Haha… The only one I’ve read that was set at Christmas was an Arthur Conan Doyle, Sherlock Holmes short story ??… It focused more on crime than Christmas lol but again I don’t like Christmas themed books, they are too soppy and light hearted for me ?

2
Reply
Anvar

it doesn’t make you Grinch, each has own and you can just put such books aside till happy hours

1
Reply
Stacy

I’m with you. Movies too.

1
Reply
Annette

If there were any good ones it might be different!

2
Reply
Vanessa

Seriously this ^ They are all cheesy to me. Romantic, perfect everything and exaggerated happiness.

1
Jilly

I find Christmassy books too full of smalch (how on earth do you spell that?) for my tastes! That’s nowadays of course. Read some when I was young….but now I am in my 60s and enjoy detective/thriller genres.

1
Reply
Jo

schmalz, and I agree 🙂

0
Storm

I’ve never read a Christmas themed book before. I picked up one today to try though. So I don’t know if I like them or not.

1
Reply
Ilona

Christmas Carol by Charles Dickens is my favourite?

5
Reply
Elizabeth

Hate them way too romancey Hallmark movieish with the exception of The Christmas Carol..that’s classic

2
Reply
Teresa

No.not my favorite

1
Reply
Vanessa

I don’t think I own one Christmas themed book, unless you count NOS4A2 by Joe Hill ??
I read fantasy & mystery/thriller which usually have some sort of winter theme. That’s enough for me xD

0
Reply
Consuella

I have never read a Christmas themed book.

0
Reply
Valerie

Too many of them have too much “sweet” for me.

2
Reply
Starla

I usually don’t read them either

0
Reply
Alex

The only Christmas book I’ve ever read is The Stupidest Angel by Christopher Moore. Most Xmas books come across as. Cheesy hallmark movies (which I admit to watching once in a blue moon). this year I picked up Skipping Christmas by John grisham. I don’t usually read him, but I love the Christmas with the Kranks movie, so thought I’d see how the book is.

1
Reply
Alex

Also got one by Sedaris, cant remember the name right now though

0
Brittany

They’re too cheesy for me. I’d be rolling my eyes at them non-stop

3
Reply
Jeni

I don’t like them, nor Christmas movies and music. I could do without the while thing actually. Christmas has turned into a commercial nightmare, in my ever so humble opinion. But I enjoy watching people who love Christmas enjoy their time.

0
Reply
Tona

I don’t do Christmas themed books or movies either

0
Reply
Aundrea

I hate pretty much everything about Christmas because I hate Christmas. The hallmark channel and Christmas music is the worst

0
Reply
Tracey

I love Christmas as does my family. My girls and I make gingerbread houses, collect for the needy, enjoy each other’s company (many board games come out), and love anything Christmas. My 16 year old daughter and I especially love the Hallmark channel Christmas shows. We watch at least one Christmas themed movie until New Year’s Eve. I love it!

2
Reply
Alex

We love Christmas in our house too 🙂

1
Yannie

I’m with you @Tracey.

2
Jo

I never noticed so many Christmas themed books in the shops before. Such cynical commercialisation goes against everything christmas represents. Perhaps they are churning them out on Orwellian novel writing machines? I wonder if it’s the same place that floods the airwaves with low on quality high on cliché Christmas movies over the past couple of years? Lol. What really amazes me is the willingness people have to accept these things as if they are some long standing tradition – when it is literally a phenomenon that began just a couple of years ago. I’m happy enough with the christmas classics (in both books and film) and don’t feel the need to fall for this to off marketing ploy.

0
Reply
Megan

The only Christmas themed book I’ve read is A Christmas Carol… and that was years ago. I don’t like all the Christmas themed movies and so on minus It’s a Wonderful Life. I don’t really care for Christmas much in general.

2
Reply
Brittany

I love Christmas books for kids, but definitely not Christmas books for myself. The only one I like is NOS4A2 by Joe Hill. ?

1
Reply
Jenna

I am not a huge fan of them either. I like Christmas movies but have never really been one to seek out Christmas books.

0
Reply
Traci

I don’t either! You’re alone ?

0
Reply
Caitlyn

I only like How the grinch stole Christmas and a chritmas carol other wise no I don’t like them

2
Reply
Ilona

I love this 2 movies as well+the latest edition of Nutcracker

0
Misty

I don’t either. I also don’t like Christmas music.

0
Reply
Heather

Nah. I’m not into them either.

0
Reply
Amanda

I must confess I’m a sucker for a Christmas book and a Christmas movie and Christmas song ?

3
Reply
Yannie

I read one book a year and enjoy it. It puts a smile on my face.

0
LaVonne

I don’t care for them – a bit on the fluffy side for my taste.

2
Reply
Christle

I love Christmas music and movies, and some Christmas-themed childrens books…The Grinch, The Nutcracker, The Polar Express…but for some reason, I seem to hate Christmas-themed adult books, and I don’t know why.

3
Reply
Dorothy

I’ve never really had feelings one way or the other toward them.

1
Reply
Melissa

I don’t think I’ve read a Christmas themed book. Books with the holiday in it yes, but not centered around it. Just a passing holiday.

1
Reply
Errin

No, I’m pretty picky… will read one if it’s given to me AND I think I might like it. Or it’s a riff on non-Christmas books where I loved the characters.

1
Reply
Barter

I like novellas like ‘A Christmas Carol’ and ‘The Story of the Other Wise Man’, and some Christmas short stories by O’Henry , Stephen Leacock and Jean Shepherd ‘s ‘A Christmas Story.Others Like the glossy romances that are run of the mill this time of year,I’m not fond of.

2
Reply
Germaine

How about a little mystery and suspense at Christmas time?

Image may contain: 1 person
2
Reply
Ann

Those look inviting.

1
Magda

I don’t think I’ve read any newer fiction that centers around a holiday, I *did* buy an ebook set (it was on sale) that I want to read, it’s a sci-fi about Santa Claus and some other winter holiday figures. The first one is called “Claus: Legend of the Fat Man,” there’s also “Jack: The Tale of Frost,” and “Flury: Journey of a Snowman” –someday I’ll actually read them and report back. ; )

1
Reply
Antoinette

I absolutely love them for my kids! But I think the only one I have as an adult is Charles Dickens A Christmas Carol that I got myself as a stocking stuffer last year. My husband has two Christmas themed Uncle John Bathroom Reader books if that counts. Lol. I don’t think I’d want another adult Christmas book unless maybe it was a Chicken Soup for the Soul versions. I’m a sucker for those.

0
Reply
Antoinette

I’ve heard good things about The Christmas Box. Has anyone read it?

0
Reply
Alana

I understand too, I’m Jewish so Christmas books never really interested me.

0
Reply
Magda

I was raised with both, which I think is why it’s interesting to me! lol I feel like there’s a hidden history, since Jews more often explain origins and explain the symbolism, and more of the Christian and contemporary holiday stuff is an amalgamation, and not as clearly explained.

0
Alana

Exactly!

0
Cindy

I can only tolerate christmas for about 2 weeks out of the year… It’s not my fault… Blame the people who start shoving christmas down your throat two weeks before Halloween.

4
Reply
Rebecca

More like 2nd week in August. Lol

1
Cindy

I crack wise about it… but honestly it’s one of the most disgusting things I feel subjected to every season… Especially when they start in on those “Buy your family’s love this year!!! Shop smart, shop S-Mart” attacks on people. As if the ONLY way you can be loved is through your bank account. It’s just filthy morals as far as I’m concerned.

0
Cindy

I like Thanksgiving better… Everyone seems more worried about the turkey turning out delicious than how much you spent on the damn bird!!

0
Christy

I love Christmas movies but really haven’t ever open eve thought of reading one May be I should try one.

0
Reply
Giselle

I have never read a Christmas themed book actually. I have too many on my TBR to add seasonal books too! lol

1
Reply
Mary

I only like the Christmas movies.

0
Reply
Mary

I am a very serious reader, usually of literary fiction, that I also edit. However, this month, for the first time ever I have read two sweet little Christmas-themed books in about one night each, laughed and cried alternately and felt better. I have been weighed down by the weight of the world so to speak, and feeling it physically as well. This was a silly, easy outlet and it has somehow cheered me up and replaced my sense of humor. You’re not a Grinch and I’m not a Pollyanna. You might try one next time you want a complete departure and forget about the TBRs. At 74, I will take rooms of them to my death bed. LOL!

1
Reply
Julieta

You are not alone.

1
Reply
Tanya

I’m a Grinch too! But I’m also Jewish.

1
Reply
Donna

Depends. I️ don’t like romance or mystery books, and most of them are Christmas themed.

1
Reply
Ann

No — most are dumb , or very similar..esp. romances.

1
Reply
Mandy

I hate anything that has to do with the holidays. I’m mrs. Scrooge. God forgive me.

1
Reply
Christine

There is a Stephanie Plum novel with elves – not that good.

0
Reply
Irene

They are boring and too easy to read.

1
Reply
Becky

I don’t like them either

0
Reply
Amanda

Reading this and finding it kinda slow and boring. Almost done though.

No photo description available.
0
Reply
Susan

Have you read John Grisham’s Skipping Christmas? Or The Best Christmas Pageant Ever? I tend to like my Christmas stories in short, humorous doses. Maybe you would too? Or you are free to skip the entire genre, if that is your preference.

2
Reply
Ann

Yes ,last year I read ” Skipping Christmas “.

1
Ann

Yep..and the best Xmas parent! ?

1
Christian

I don’t like Christmas in general.

0
Reply
Susan

I’m reading Last Christmas in Paris and I like it. Usually the holiday books don’t seem as well written.

0
Reply
Grace

I just finished reading one today because it was for my book club. The whole time I just kept saying, “I’m reading a Hallmark movie. This is SO cheesy!” I did enjoy it, but I had to put aside some of my “issues” with little things like consistency in the plot, overused tropes, and unrealistic dialogue. 😉

0
Reply
Grace

Some day I’m going to write a satirical Christmas book that is just over-the-top cheese…. Someday…

0
Reply
Sylvia

I don’t like em much either.

0
Reply
Tammy

I like some, but most of them wax cheesy or trite.

1
Reply
Yannie

I recently read “The Dog who came over for Christmas’ and it was a good book. It had a nice meaning to it. I usually like to read one that has to do with a rescue animal or one who is a service dog like this book had. Now I am going back to my regular read. I do this during the Halloween season too. This year I read “IT” .

1
Reply
Yannie

One last thing to me. With all the stuff in the news, it’s nice to read a pleasant book especially if it’s Christmas themed. It puts a smile on my face.

2
Reply
Shannon

I don’t think I’ve read many Christmas themed books. I like a Christmas Carol by Charles Dickens, but I’m not sure I’ve read much else (excluding a few children’s books) hmmm … maybe I should branch out… ?

0
Reply
Yannie

They are just good fun I think and like I said I just read a couple around the season to cheer me up.

1
Erin

Same! I LOVE Christmas movies but can’t stand Christmas books!

0
Reply
Disa

Yes!

0
Reply
Disa

Just needed to be contrary. Don’t mind me.

0
Lela

I read a Christmas Grace by Anne Perry and it is a murder mystery that was entertaining. I thought.

0
Reply
Leave a Answer Cancel

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Loading Please wait
Log in
Register
Categories
  • get the book
  • questionnaire
  • recommend
  • review
Genres
animal art biography business chick lit classics comics contemporary cookbooks crime detective fantasy fiction gay and lesbian graphic novel historical fiction history horror humor and comedy kids languages manga memoir music mystery nonfiction novel paranormal philosophy poetry psychology religies religion romance scary science science fiction self help spirituality sports suspense thriller travel young adult young adults
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions

2019 © TheBookSwarm