TheBookSwarm
Ask Question

Who do you like better Clary Fray or Emma Carstairs

Who do you like better

Clary Fray or Emma Carstairs

Christopher #questionnaire

16
Reply

80 Answers

JoLeen

Clary Fray!

0
Reply
Paige

Emma 10000000000%. I HATED Clary.

2
Reply
Antonette

Emma

0
Reply
Cecilia

Both ?
I can’t choose ??

0
Reply
Amy

Oh jeez that’s a hard one…but I think Emma.

0
Reply
Marissa

Emma

0
Reply
Bobbie

Tessa gray

8
Reply
Elizabeth

Tessa

6
Reply
Susan

Who is Emma?

0
Reply
JoLeen

She’s from the Dark Artifices, but is introduced in City of Heavenly Fire.

0
Cecilia

It’s one of the new protagonists from The Dark Artifices, I think

0
Susan

@JoLeen huh i don’t remember her but I read city of fire ages ago.

0
Cecilia

Yes, the Dark Artifices

0
Cecilia

It happens after City of Heavenly Fire

0
JoLeen

@Susan she is related to Jem Carstairs from the Infernal Devices

0
Cecilia

I think Emma is introduced in that book?

0
Susan

@Cecilia oh ok. I don’t think I ever finished that book. Lost interest halfway through. Should go back and read it again.

1
Christie

Emma

0
Reply
Jennifer

Clary

1
Reply
Ranya

Haven’t read TDA yet but I already like Emma better from What I’ve read about her in TMI

0
Reply
Faith

Tessa

5
Reply
Susan

Tessa Gray.

4
Reply
McKenna

Clary

1
Reply
Meg

Tessa

1
Reply
Adreanna

Emma

0
Reply
Cassie

Emma and Tessa

1
Reply
Rian

Emma

0
Reply
Kalix

EMMA

0
Reply
Avonlea

Emma

0
Reply
Jazzmine

Clary

0
Reply
Emily

I love both so much ? Clary is an OG for me though, and Emma’s story isn’t over yet so I don’t think I can decide

0
Reply
Ashley

Clary and Tessa

0
Reply
Carey

Tessa is the best!

0
Ashley

Emma

0
Reply
Leigh

Emma

0
Reply
Rachel

Emma.

0
Reply
Carey

Emma

0
Reply
Calmen

Emma

0
Reply
Mary

Emma

0
Reply
Ivandri

EMMA!

0
Reply
Thê

EMMA CARSTAIRS

0
Reply
Tin

Clary

0
Reply
Debbie

Clary

0
Reply
BreAna

Tessa

2
Reply
Dorothy

I’m sorry, but Tessa Gray

3
Reply
Michele

Tessaaaa ? haha

2
Reply
Kristina

@Michele Tessa all the way!

1
Diana

Emma

0
Reply
Ava

Emma, sorry Fray.

0
Reply
Marissa

Clary 100%

0
Reply
Shivani

Tessa Gray and Emma Carstairs ?

0
Reply
Ivett

I did not like Clary, but I cannot stand Emma. So yes, Tessa was the only likeable main character in the Shadowhunter books.

1
Reply
Meagan

Emma because she just seems more determined and not so vanilla..? Like I like Clary but she just doesn’t seem like she does anything wrong? It’s kind of hard to picture her wanting to be in an incestual relationship ?

0
Reply
Kaytlyn

Clary

0
Reply
Janette

Can’t choose, both are admirable and very strong.

0
Reply
Béa

Emma is more badass than clary

0
Reply
Lena

Emma!

0
Reply
Ruby

Clary 🙂

0
Reply
Sydney

Clary

0
Reply
Skylar

Tessa

4
Reply
Hannah

I haven’t read TDA yet but I’m Clary 100% over annoying Tessa!!!

1
Reply
Mariana

Clary

0
Reply
Ann

Clary

0
Reply
Emma

Emma

2
Reply
Béa

@Emma hence your name lol

1
Emma

@Béa lol!!!!my name indicate my obsession with her!!!

0
Kristen

Emma

0
Reply
Zoe

Clash but Tessa is the favourite

1
Reply
Léa

That’s a hard choice. Can I say Jace and Julian?

1
Reply
Rebeca

Emma! 100%

0
Reply
Sonya

Emma

0
Reply
Robyn

Clary

0
Reply
Ale

Emma, cause it’s like a female version of Jace ?? and I love her cause she’s so fearless and badass!?

3
Reply
Nicole

Clary

0
Reply
Jennifer

Out of the two I would pick Emma because I find her to be better character than Clary. I haven’t read the Dark Artifices series yet but I think that I’ll still like her then. I like Emma’s backstory, I like her family, friends, her courage, passion, intelligence, individuality, strength, power, and personality. But if it was Emma against Tessa, I think I would pick Tessa.

1
Reply
Morgan

Emmaaa

0
Reply
Kevin

do what the author recommends, and intended, read it first.

0
Reply
ChristopherQuestion author

Lol what? I have read the Shadowhunters books. What makes you think I haven’t?

0
Kevin

clearly I typed this comment on the wrong post. on my news feed the next post is about assasins blade read order. I am sure I ment it to go there.

1
ChristopherQuestion author

Yeah…okay…

0
Leave a Answer Cancel

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Loading Please wait
Log in
Register
Categories
  • get the book
  • questionnaire
  • recommend
  • review
Genres
animal art biography business chick lit classics comics contemporary cookbooks crime detective fantasy fiction gay and lesbian graphic novel historical fiction history horror humor and comedy kids languages manga memoir music mystery nonfiction novel paranormal philosophy poetry psychology religies religion romance scary science science fiction self help spirituality sports suspense thriller travel young adult young adults
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions

2019 © TheBookSwarm