TheBookSwarm
Ask Question

What movie do you think is the best adaptation from a book you’ve read?

What movie do you think is the best adaptation from a book you’ve read?

Amber #questionnaire

15
Reply

64 Answers

Lindsey

I honestly loved the Harry Potter movies IDC what anyone says lol.

& Lincoln Lawyer

14
Reply
Michaela

Me too!

1
Yannie

I agree. Great actors too!

1
Stephanie

And Me 🙂

1
Diana

Gone Girl. I felt the movie really captured the book.

0
Mari

I also loved the Harry Potter ones….and Hunger games

11
Reply
Carli

I agree about the Harry potter ones and hunger games. I also enjoyed the Hobbit and Lord of the rings.

9
Reply
Sachika

Pride and Predujice with Keira Knightly (did I spell that wrong?) The story was very precisely tailored to the book, and was exactly as I’d expected the story to feel like.

5
Reply
Carli

I liked that one as well. But I like the one with Collin Firth a little better. but both are good.

5
Yannie

That is one of my favorite movies with one of my favorite actresses. (Keira’s version)

2
Sachika

Harry Potter series was good and all, but not the best adaptation I’ve ever seen, so…

0
Reply
Yamileth

The Host by Stephanie Meyer. I loved the book and it does have certain scenes missing but I honestly loved it.

6
Reply
Katelyn

I agree!!!

1
Faith

The Hunger Games hands down. They just got better and better. And the acting was just so well done as well as the world building. It really felt like I was experiencing what I had in the book and to be honest I liked the Mockingjay movies better then the book.

9
Reply
Brittany

I agree. I thought they did it absolutely perfectly.

0
Laura

I agree x

1
Kristina

For me… Interview with a Vampire

4
Reply
Mita

I enjoyed the movie version of Gone Girl.

4
Reply
Tori

Not movie but series. I think Outlander did a fantastic job

4
Reply
Elizabeth

Yesssss!!!!!

0
Siri

The Godfather—1&2! Although, The Princess Bride is a very close second!???

1
Reply
Michaela

Spud was pretty good ? as a fellow South African I’m so proud of that movie adaption to the book ?

1
Reply
Diane

I agree with Tori – Outlander is very well done

4
Reply
Yannie

I could never get into the books and tried about three times. Love the show though.

2
Lisa

Me Before You and The Hunger Games. For TV – Outlander.

2
Reply
Belu

I hated Harry Potter 4 and 6. It was nothing like the book…

2
Reply
Yannie

I liked books 1-4 a lot. The others were good too but not amazing.

0
Riannon

A Monster Calls. It was just perfect!

1
Reply
Yannie

I want to see that but didn’t read the book.

0
Siobhan

Love love love this book!!

0
Catherine

Glad to hear this. I love that book but haven’t seen the movie yet.

0
Belu

The Lord of the rings, true blood was better than the book , but not a loyal adaptation. The first season of game of thrones is good af

3
Reply
Tori

lol I disagree, especially on the True blood account… they went so far away from the plot it was ridiculous.

1
Yannie

The Lord of the Rings. It was made even better than the book and I read all the books

2
Reply
Belu

Ohh yeag

1
Tori

I loved LOTR movies but for me books were way better…. movies cut too much out

1
Yannie

Homeward Bound (the newer movie.). I loved the book as a child.

0
Reply
Stephanie

The hunger games, definitely.

1
Reply
Nikol

TFIOS and Catching fire were pretty good

0
Reply
Jessica

All of the Hunger Games movies

1
Reply
Kryssi

Stephen King’s Green Mile. It was seriously word-for-word exact.

2
Reply
Melissa

The Shawshank Redemption is pretty close to the story. I also loved the Hunger Games movies. They did not disappoint me.

1
Reply
Jessica

Water for elephants is a great adaptation

2
Reply
AmberQuestion author

I still need to read this book! Been sitting in my kindle for years ?

0
Milagros

The Kite Runner

2
Reply
Dana

Holes

4
Reply
Stacy

This book was great. I’ve never seen the movie.

0
AmberQuestion author

I still need to read this book!

0
Catherine

I also enjoyed both the book and movie of this.

0
Stacy

Gone With the Wind- hands down, all time favorite. ThornBirds, The North and The South, Roots (the original) were all excellent mini series.

2
Reply
Tori

Which North and the south?

0
Stacy

I’m sorry @Tori! I was typing faster than my brain was thinking. I did enjoy The North and The South and always thought it would make a great book series!

1
Linda

i would agree, Gone with the wind!

1
Tori

There are multiple versions of North and the South series…. I was just curious which version you thought was best

0
Chelsea

Fight Club and Fear and Loathing in Las Vegas.

0
Reply
Linda

Little Women

0
Reply
Rachel

The Outsiders

2
Reply
Deborah

Perfume

0
Reply
Richard

the neverending story

0
Reply
Gabby

The road

0
Reply
Catherine

I like Bridge to Terabithia as much as the book. I liked the movie The Mighty better than the book Freak the Mighty.

0
Reply
Storm

Of mice & men. The screen play. Best thing I’ve ever watched. It was just like the book.

1
Reply
Melissa

Harry Potter movies.

1
Reply
Daphne

The harry potters weren’t that bad but if im being honest nothing can ever beat the book. If I had to pick the best I’d say The Outsiders

0
Reply
Leave a Answer Cancel

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Loading Please wait
Log in
Register
Categories
  • get the book
  • questionnaire
  • recommend
  • review
Genres
animal art biography business chick lit classics comics contemporary cookbooks crime detective fantasy fiction gay and lesbian graphic novel historical fiction history horror humor and comedy kids languages manga memoir music mystery nonfiction novel paranormal philosophy poetry psychology religies religion romance scary science science fiction self help spirituality sports suspense thriller travel young adult young adults
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions

2019 © TheBookSwarm