What film adaptation is just as good as the novel on which it is based?
What film adaptation is just as good as the novel on which it is based?
307 Answers
You must be logged in to post a comment.
Loading Please wait
What film adaptation is just as good as the novel on which it is based?
Eragon by paolini.
The Help
Fight Club
Gone with the Wind (better than the movie)
Life of Pi
Also better than the movie
Gone girl
Time traveler’s wife
Wizard of Oz movies is better!
The Martian
Yep I’ll agree here, I thought they did great on the movie
@Kelli and I lived loved
Agree, the books are always gonna be a bit more imaginative but this one was pretty great, and I’m so glad they didn’t conform to society’s idealism and they kept him single without children. I like when they stick to the original story.
The Outlander Series
I agree!! They are doing pretty well!
Gone With the Wind
Lonesome Dove
The book thief
Personally I think the book is way better
There is a movie? ??
I find books are always better than the film, but still enjoyed it
Yes Menna there’s a film ?
The Martian
Okay, it was good and the science was right but they really should have spent more time showing the trip from the hab to the launch site. There was so much that happened!
The 100 year old man….
Swedish/English version
I loved the book. I must see the movie
That’s a movie?
Hated the book but i guess it makes a good comedy movie. I have to watch it
Apparently Will Ferrell is producing and directing another film version too, not sure when it’s out tho.
I really was shocked at how good the movie Wonder was. I have new respect for Owen Wilson
I need to see that. Loved the book.
Twilight. It’s easier to watch than deal with the schmaltzy writing!
Sadly I don’t mind the movies ?
Prince of Tides
Haven’t read it in years, and I found this book again at a sale❤️actually got it for free?
No way!!! I thought the movie was horrible…and I loved the book. Barbra Streisand did terrible things to the story line, in my opinion. She made it all about her.
Ugh, no way. I like Barbara but not in that mess.
I have to agree with the dissenters, although I did like the movie, with the exception of Barbra Streisand…kept expecting her to break into song.
But the book, oh my God, the book! So powerful, such beautiful writing, the sadness of living stuck in a secret, was so well presented by Conroy. It reinforces for me the belief that truly gifted writers always put some of their own biography into their books…be it events, or the feelings they’ve had. With Conroy I always FEEL his stories.
Pat Conroy is/was one of my very favorite writers.
Lonesome Dove.
The Hunger Games is actually better than the book since you sent stuck in the head of Katniss. That makes her more likable
I loved hearing her thoughts.
Lonesome Dove was the first-ever mini-series I watched and I remember it being amazing. I later watched North and South and Shogun.
Yeah i thought the hunger games was pretty close.
I really liked ‘Love, Simon’ recently. My all time favourite movie based on books is the LOTR series. Also somehow the Borne series was an amazing adaptation.
Me before you
The Godfather
I think the movie was even better.
Agree.. the movie was far better.
Most novels are way more interesting than their movie adaptations. Movies generally leave out some of my favorite scenes, and don’t have time to develop minor characters.
The Godfather
The Princess Bride (movie is better)
Shutter Island
The Shining (unpopular opinion-the movie is better)
Definitely agree with The Princess Bride. I love the movie and the book was just meh.
The Firm was better as a movie. I thought the ending was more clever.
On the other hand, the movie of Not Without My Daughter was terrible compared to the book
Most novels are far better than any film adaptation. USually I only enjoy the film more if I didn’t care much for the book.
The Bridges of Madison county, I loved the book and movie.
The Prestige — though it is markedly different from the novel.
Thinking…
Dead zone
The english patient by Michael Ondaatje
Not many. Only one I can think of is Hunger Games
I agree. The Capital was exactly as I imagined it when reading the book.
Besides the ending they did a great job. Maybe the ending in the book confused me and the did it the way it was ??♀️??
Watchmen!
LOTR is almost as good as the book… Epic trilogy it was
True
Not AS good but super amazing. I love those movies. We just rewatched all three.
Priness Bride, Thief Lord, and The Last Unicorn.
Thief Lord ? have to rewatch it
It was really close to the book. Did you read the book?
When I was very young so don’t remember to much ?
It’s a great book at any age and definitely worth a reread.
I will have to see if i can find it in english
I feel like half price books, at least the one by me, usually has a copy.
Sadly her most stores have mainly German if not only German
The Last Unicorn was a book?? I remember seeing it in a movie theatre with my mother when I was a teenager! Thank you for bringing back such a special memory. 🙂 Now tell me, was Labrynth a book too?? (Be still my heart, lol!) 🙂
To kill a mockingbird.
Fight Club
The writer preferred the movie.
@Dan, I didn’t know that. He is a very nice guy (Chuck P); my son has been to several of his readings and signings. He always poses for pictures and talks to his fans.
@Stacy my friend said the same thing. Don’t know if his signings are for everyone, there’s a lot of adult toys brought to him to sign.
@Katie, not for everyone, for sure, although if you enjoy his books, you sort of know what you are in for, lol. ?
Lord of the Flies
Yes and no….still, the movie was good, the book better. It’s just so hard to depict thoughts, and a lot of what goes on in Simon and Piggy’s heads, just wasn’t represented that well
I agree with Gene. Although Wanda you are right about the thoughts which you cannot see in the movie, it gave me pretty much the same amount of creeps as the book and made me feel like something very wrong is happening on that island from the very beginning. I enjoy that. (I think there are two movies, I loved the older version more)
The Shawshank Redemption is an astounding film but I’m not sure if it’s better than the book.
Well I think it was a short story..which was ok, but this is one of my all-time favorite movies … but that could be because of Morgan Freeman
Was just going to say this one. Both movie and novella are great. I can’t turn the movie off if I happen to catch it.
The girl with all the gifts
Dances with wolves
One day
Winter’s Bone
The boy in the striped pajamas
I personally thought the book was way better but in saying that i did not see the ending coming so that emotional shock factor made the book better for me. Not sure if id think the other way if i saw the movie first
To Kill a Mockingbird
Stand by me
The Green Mile
The Shipping News was very good!
Another favorite
Fight club
The Firm
They changed the ending!
@Ginger thanks it has been a long time since reading and seeing the movie.
The Help!
The Green Mile
The notebook
Last Orders
Brooklyn
Charlie and the Chocolate Factory
The Revenant
Ghost Walker
Which version of Charlie and the Chocolate Factory tho?
The Green Mile
Blade Runner
Fight Club
Gone girl
The Handmaid’s Tale (TV) is very well done
First blood
The green mile
The Shining
NO. I hated the movie
Jack Nicholson made the whole movie worth it
but I agree that kubrick’s style was a bit much (with the river of blood)
Yes Kubricks version is my favorite. I can never get through the version of it, with the guy from wings.
They left out or glazed over so many of my favorite parts of the book. The film is amazing still…
Yes, the movie was different than the book, especially the ending, but try rereading and imagine Jack Nicholson’s acting…. extra chills!
@Venus no. I’m sorry I disagree
The Martian
Hidden Figures, The Martian, Room with a View, Pride & Prejudice
Outlander.
To Kill a Mockingbird
No!! They left out main characters
@Ellen I thought the editing was great. What was removed was not necessary to tell the story and keep its integrity.
The perks of being a wallflower
Gone with the wind
Papillon came close. Both were amazing.
My pick too
The series of unfortunate events…the movie adaptation, not the show.
Twilight series (no one kill me for actually enjoying these books)
I agree with your Twilight comment. I actually liked how they changed the ending a bit in the movie.
I loooove the movie adaptation and honestly I prefer the twilight movies over the books
Water for Elephants. Loved the book, loved the movie.
Atonement
Life of Pi
Fried Green Tomatoes and Jaws
Green Mile
Agreed! It was perfect as far as adaptations go!
Practical Magic.
LOVE this movie and used the song Crystalline from it at our wedding! Now my IRL book club is reading it later this year and it will be the first time I’ve read the book of a long-loved-favorite movie. I hope it lives up!
Yes! Me too! Just thinking about it makes me want to curl up and watch it, lol. I hope you like book too. You’ll have to let me know your thoughts on if after you read it.
Following
I liked the movie better
@Cassie yes. Me too.
Anatomy of a Murder
Gone with the wind
I haven’t read the book yet but I watched WONDER and it’s beautiful, same thing with A MAN CALLED OVE
The English Patient
The Godfather
Agree and then the masterpiece without a book; Godfather II
Into the Wild
The Outsiders. Misery.
Oh, yes, Misery! Definitely even better as a book.
I was going to say Misery too! I think it’s the only movie I enjoyed more than the book.
Howl’s Moving Castle! The plot varies enough that you can appreciate them as two different stories, but the whimsical feeling is exactly the same for both.
Gone with the wind
Call Me By Your Name
I didn’t think it could be done, but Outlander.
I haven’t found one yet. I can say I LOVED The Martian & all of the Harry Potter movies.
Honestly, and I don’t know if someone is like me but once I read the book I can’t watch the movie, I don’t know why but I feel like I have made to that book my own characters and their own faces lol so I can’t watch the movie
The Green Mile
Ready Player One was so good as a stand alone film. You could definitely enjoy it without having read the book.
I disagree. I thought the movie was TERRIBLE compared to the book. All my friends who read the book agreed. Seemed the people I know who loved the movie hadn’t read the book…
I havent seen the movie yet but that book, SO GOOD.
@Amber one of my favorites! which is probably why I was so disappointed in the movie.
I had high hopes for it cause its Spielberg but I also told myself to wait. Alot of my friends loved it but its the same as you, they didnt read the book, @Randi.
@Randi, i said as a stand alone, it was a great movie. I was able to separate the 2.
Harry Potter
Practical Magic
Movie is actually better then the book imo which never happens!
I thought the movie was much better than the book which surprised me
The Bridges of Madison County. Actually thought movie was much better than book.
The Help
The outsiders
Gone with the wind ❤❤❤
Me Before You.
The Green Mile
Chocolat and Practical Magic, both much better than the books.
Secret Life of Bees…
Loved the book so very much!! I can’t imagine the movie being better but I will now check it out.
@Brenda, movies are rarely better, but this Is a very good adaptation… stayed true to the book.
The Road, Fight Club, The Martian, Room, The Lost City of Z.
Girl with the dragon tattoo
If you combine both versions lol
This is on my “To-Read” List
The World According To Garp.
Hunger games
I disagree. They left out Madge in every movie ?
Fried Green Tomatoes ?
Girl with the dragon tattoo….all of the trilogy in the swedish version..top notch
The Shawshank Redemption.
Outlander
100%
I love the show, but am more abt the books
I love this! Gone With the Wind was the 1st one I thought of. Also Charlie and the Chocolate Factory (with Gene Wilder), Harry Potter, Lord of the Rings, A Christmas Story, East of Eden. I’m interested now in reading Practical Magic – it’s been ages since I saw the movie!!
definitely gone with the wind. loved that as a kid, book and movie 🙂
Thomas Tryon’s, “The Other”.
Old ones and longer than usual films but: Our Mutual Friend and Lonsesome Dove
One of the few movies I thought did full justice to the novel.
Michael Chabon – Wonder Boys
The Gradute. No Country For Old Men. Housekeeping. Gone Girl. Annihilation.
Joy Luck Club
The Princess Bride. The only movie I will say is actually better than the book.
I love both. I especially love the chapter with Inigo and Fezzik in the zoo of death and the deeper backstories.
OMFG, i didnt even know it was a book!!!!!!!
@Amber the book is funnier and more outlandish than the movie–definitely worth checking out!
The Cider House Rules.
Fight Club
Fight Club
Fried Green Tomatoes and The Guernsey Literary and Potato Peel Pie Society
The Help
The Witches by Dahl!
Jaws
To Kill a Mockingbird
The 1980s version of A Room With A View.
The Secret Life of Bees, Fried Green Tomatoes, Jurassic Park, To Kill a Mockingbird, The Name of the Rose.
Hunger Games
Green Mile
Atonement
Pride and Prejudice
The Princess Bride. Both incredibly good in their own way
To Kill A Mockingbird, The Help, Princess Bride, Gone With the Wind, Maltese Falcon. I really enjoyed Girl with the dragon tattoo, and hunger games in both forms, although the books are slightly better.
The Color Purple
Oh and Wise Guys which got made into Goodfellas and Donnie Branco are great mob movies. I’m sure Godfather can’t get any better than the films but I haven’t read the book(s).
The Outsiders
Definitely was a great movie and followed the book. It’s one of my all time favorite books and movies! I read it first time in 6th grade and loved it. I cried! Stay golden!
Agree with this! I loved this book so much in 8th grade I stole it after my teacher said I couldn’t keep it. Whoops. Movie has always been a fave of mine!!
Lonesome Dove.
It was great and the book won a Pulitzer…
Harry Potter in my oppinion (wouldn’t have really done it any different even if I knew how ?)
I would have 1) included peeves. How could they leave him out 2) had Dumbledore actually speak calmly when asking Harry if he put his name in the goblet of fire??♀️
Well Peeves would have been cool but I don’t think he was that important for the story development and true that is one think I would change. Breath Dumbledore ?
True, he is not important for story development- I just really feel like he could have made the movies that much better lol
It would have been nice to show him maybe once or twice but even in the books he is more important at the beginning
Pride & Prejudice 2005
I would have to say, To Kill A Mockingbird.
The Lincoln Lawyer
The matchmaker’s playbook ??
The Help
THE help
One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest
Wild
Gone With the Wind, Christine and Delores Claiborne.
The Martian
Call Me By Your Name, Brooklyn. Both of those I actually loved the films more!
I agree with Brooklyn! 🙂
Chocolat
Room
A Man Called Ove
Gone with the Wind
Emma — the 1996 movie produced by (gasp!) Weinstein and others — is better than the book. To those who hold Jane Austen sacred, that’s only an opinion!
The 1996 film was brilliant!!
@AnneMcCrary …. One of the few I own ~
Hunger games
Me before you
The Da Vinci Code. It’s the only instance I can think of where the unrealistic and unnecessary romantic ending is changed and improved in the movie to a non-romantic friendship.
Lord of the Rings
Room
And white oleander
hunger games
The Namesake
Gone With the Wind, To Kill a Mockingbird, the Bourne books and so many. Only two movies better than the books: Forest Gump and Field of Dreams.
Oh, I loved the movie Field of Dreams!! Had no idea it’s also a book. Thank you!!
“Hidden Figures” movie is much better than the book.
I like the movie adaptation of Legally Blonde even BETTER than the book! That’s a first for me.
LOtR is pretty epic
Outlander.
Rebecca by Daphne Du Maurier
From 1940 or 1997?
Never Let Me Go
Like Water for Chocolate
Wonder, Like Water For Chocolate, The Perks of Being A Wallflower, Me And Earl And The Dying Girl
“Persuasion” The BBC version with Amanda Root.
I don’t know . I have never seen a movie than can top my imagination .
I like that, Leann Curtis.
Prince of Tides comes close.
The Godfather
The name of the rose
For me the books are always better. But for me to enjoy the movies it doesn’t necessarily have to be a scene for scene shot of the book (but that helps)
These are the movies I enjoyed even after reading the book
Harry Potter (sorcerers stone only)
Gone girl
Stardust (I actually liked the movie better!)
Ready Player One (book and movie are different but equally great)
Water for elephants
Pride and prejudice (Colin firth)
The witches
Matilda
Jurassic park
The other boelyn girl
The lion the witch and the wardrobe
Something borrowed
Along came a spider
The maze runner
Where the Red Fern Grows
Harry Potter, Bridget Jones and Twilight for me.
Jurassic Park
Harry Potter ⚡️
Books are always better… You wait excitedly for the movie to come out but its never as good as you imagined. Sometimes you know just from the trailer! I’ve just finished reading Ready Player One and I thought about watching the movie… Shall I bother?
Of Mice and Men.
Broke my heart….can’t ever watch or read it again
I read it at age 12….it had a profound effect on me…..
I recently watched a man called ove and loved the movie. Was very good. I realised how much I missed ove since finishing the book
The Five People You Meet in Heaven.
The Hunger Games.
Gone with the Wind
The Notebook and Brooklyn are the only two movies I’ve seen so far that topped the book (in my opinion).
Jaws
Memoirs of a Geisha and Stardust
The Bourne series and Lord of the Rings?
The Secret Garden – 1993 movie.
Who is the author of the book, there are several with that title.
Frances Hodgson Burnett.
Gone With The Wind, the movie leaves a lot out but it is four hours long so easy to see why. Otherwise, it follows the book and many places it’s verbatim.
Whaaaaaat??? Seriously?