TheBookSwarm
Ask Question

Should I read first: The Night Circus My Sisters Keeper

Should I read first:

The Night Circus

My Sisters Keeper

Bryn #recommend

20
Reply

45 Answers

Jolly

My sister’s keeper!! Loved it!

0
Reply
Megan

Night Circus

1
Reply
Frances

My sisters keeper make sure you have a box of tissues handy

0
Reply
BrynQuestion author

Hopefully it’s better than the movie! I cried during the movie so I know the book will be even more of a tear jerker ?

0
Lucy

Night Circus

1
Reply
Siri

The Night Circus!!❤️❤️❤️

0
Reply
Tahnee

Night circus

0
Reply
April

night circus

0
Reply
Stephanie

I really enjoyed My Sisters Keeper but couldn’t get into The Night Circus… I hope you enjoy whatever you choose 🙂

1
Reply
Brenna

Night Circus!! ?

0
Reply
Leon

Nc

0
Reply
Brandy

Night Circus

1
Reply
Sonia

Night circus. Better ending.

0
Reply
MaryLou

Night Circus. Not predictable!!

0
Reply
Chrissie

Night Circus.

0
Reply
Maryellen

Night Circus!

0
Reply
Sandy

My sister keeper

0
Reply
Angel

You can’t go wrong either way. Very different stories, but both very good stories.

0
Reply
Tina

my sisters keeper ?

0
Reply
Amanda

My Sister’s Keeper!

0
Reply
Ella

Night Circus

0
Reply
Mary

My Sister’s Keeper.

1
Reply
Agnieszka

My Sister’s Keeper was fun until the ending totally pissed me off.

0
Reply
Cecilia

Fun?

0
Christy

Night Circus is the best

1
Reply
BrynQuestion author

I guess I’ll go with night circus! I got both books for a dollar at goodwill and they are in perfect condition! I was so excited about this lol

1
Reply
Laressa

The night circus

1
Reply
Barter

Night Circus

1
Reply
Lisa

I have the Night Circus, read it & liked it. Haven’t read the other one yet…

0
Reply
Brenda

My Sister’s Keeper

0
Reply
Clare

Both very good books, I guess it would depend on your mood. If you’re ready for sad go with My Sisters Keeper, but Night Circus is pure escapism.

3
Reply
Rhea

Loved My Sisters Keeper… Just bought Night Circus yesterday, so I cannot comment

0
Reply
Mary

My Sisters Keeper is excellent, but very sad. From other comments, I assume Night Circus is more upbeat.

0
Reply
Erin

The Night Circus

0
Reply
Paige

The Night Circus ✔️

0
Reply
Grace

My sisters keeper

0
Reply
Sarah

Im reading night circus now

0
Reply
Kristen

Sister’s Keeper!

0
Reply
Katrina

The Night Circus

0
Reply
Oel

Night Circus

0
Reply
Cecilia

Loved each, both great but very different. You have to be very imaginative for Night Circus, imho. Although MSK is heartbreaking it’s incredible! Jodi is a fabulous author, one of my faves <3 I vote My Sisters Keeper ☺ Happy reading!

1
Reply
Shannon

My Sister’s Keeper

0
Reply
Dharmendra

My Sister’s Keeper

1
Reply
Bethany

I would recommend Night Circus fist and then My Sister’s Keeper. That is the order I would read them in

1
Reply
Tina

Hmmm, choices

0
Reply
Leave a Answer Cancel

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Loading Please wait
Log in
Register
Categories
  • get the book
  • questionnaire
  • recommend
  • review
Genres
animal art biography business chick lit classics comics contemporary cookbooks crime detective fantasy fiction gay and lesbian graphic novel historical fiction history horror humor and comedy kids languages manga memoir music mystery nonfiction novel paranormal philosophy poetry psychology religies religion romance scary science science fiction self help spirituality sports suspense thriller travel young adult young adults
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions

2019 © TheBookSwarm