After the hype I was disappointed with I am Pilgrim, however I saw it through to the end. Our book group loved Room as we are all mothers. Lively discussions followed reading Room. I am Pilgrim is too thick for our reading group to contemplate.
Really enjoyed I am pilgrim , recommend it too so many people . One of those books I couldn’t put down . Room was a book club book I found ok but not as good as all the hype for it . Found the mum / kidnapped women a character I didn’t really like , far to weak and selfish
Loved both.
I’m halfway through pilgrim and am really enjoying it. Read room enjoyed that in a different way
Enjoyed Room. I am Pilgrim I have found hard to get into, but on my third attempt I think I am getting there.
Loved both.
Pilgrim a trillion times better than Room. Room ending let it down for me. Pilgrim is my favourite book to date
Both!
Loved room but didn’t enjoy I am pilgrim- too heavy!
Room was very good, alot of it made me cry. highly recommend it.
Loved Pilgrim. Really hated Room.
Loved Room, wonderfully original and very clever writing.
Not read Pilgrim so can’t comment, but I think I might based on the comments above! 🙂
Amazing and fantastic!
Tried 4 times with Pilgrim….gave it up in the end !
I am reading Pilgrim and it hasnt hit the spot yet… But here’s to hoping
Loved room. Thought I am pilgrim was good but over rated. Two completely different books so depends on what you like to read.
Loved Room! Highly recommend it!
Loved both –
Totally different tho.
Loved Pilgrim, hated the concept of Room.
Room was intense
I found Room to be disturbing…I am Pilgrim is on my TBR list
Room was really dark but good, not read pilgrim yet
After the hype I was disappointed with I am Pilgrim, however I saw it through to the end. Our book group loved Room as we are all mothers. Lively discussions followed reading Room. I am Pilgrim is too thick for our reading group to contemplate.
If anyone is interested, l saw l am Pilgrim in Sainsburys for £3.99
Loved both!
BOTH!!! ?
Not sure I really got into pilgrim but hubby liked it
Loved Pilgrim!
Neither. Lol
I loved Pilgrim …. Surprised how many of you didn’t … Again shows our diverse taste which is fab ? Haven’t read Room yet!
Room is one of my favorite books! Excellent!
Pilgrim is just an incredible book. Room is an interesting read.
I loved them both,they stay with you for a long time.
Really enjoyed I am pilgrim , recommend it too so many people . One of those books I couldn’t put down . Room was a book club book I found ok but not as good as all the hype for it . Found the mum / kidnapped women a character I didn’t really like , far to weak and selfish
Both really good reads. I thought Room was very good but i enjoyed I am pilgrim more, full of suspense and twists
Room is a brilliant book, probably in my top 10 of all time.
Both brill. Both very different. Room took some getting into. I am pilgrim took some sticking with. Both very well worth reading
Room was great -couldn’t put it down.
Couldn’t get into Pilgrim!
I wasn’t a huge fan of Room. Everyone raved about it… I thought it was just ok.
Such an amazing book.
Love, love, love I Am Pilgrim!
I guess I’m in the minority… I thought I Am Pilgrim was way over-rated.
Loved I am Pilgrim but wasnt keen on Room x
Loved both 🙂
Room was a fabulous book, really enjoyed it.
I am Pilgrim, an excellent book
Loved Pilgrim!
Room
I AM Pilgrim!!!!
Room is extraordinary
I thought both were very good.
Agreed Janine Bloch…but I think ‘Pilgrim’ had the edge….