TheBookSwarm
Ask Question

MEMOIRS Love them or Hate them?

MEMOIRS

Love them

or

Hate them?

Bob #questionnaire #memoir

38
Reply

70 Answers

Kevin

Love them…among my favorite (Bio, Autobios, and Letters, too)

3
Reply
BobQuestion author

Letters are a favorite of mine as well.

0
Cassandra

❤️❤️

1
Reply
Disa

Depends on the memoir I guess. It’s a truly difficult art to make a life into a narrative without it being either boring or untruthful.

1
Reply
BobQuestion author

It really depends on the life lived of an individual. Memoirs pertain to overcoming great odds appeal to me most. The Autumn Balloon by Kenny Porpora is one example.

2
Jeanette

Excellent point!

0
Valerie

I’ve read some and liked some.

0
Reply
BobQuestion author

Care to share one that you liked?

0
Tiffany

I am reading “Talking as fast as I can” and I really like that. And all of Amy Pohler’s are really funny.

0
Agnieszka

I agree that they are often hit or miss

0
Reply
BobQuestion author

Is there a hit that you’d like to share?

0
Jill

Depends. I have to be really into the person I am reading about.

1
Reply
BobQuestion author

Sure. That’s understandable.

1
Papillon

Love them ❤

1
Reply
Gail

I love your name!

1
Tiffany

Depends. I’m actually writing a memoir right now.. I’m hoping everyone finds my adventures as interesting as I do. 😛

1
Reply
BobQuestion author

That’s fantastic! I’m a firm believer that everyone should write their story, even if they decide to share it only with future generations of their own family.

1
Tiffany

I am too. I have not lived a mundane life, but even those that have can help someone else in their stories. That’s my belief.

0
Kevin

Janet Malcolm wrote an insightful study of the various biographies of Sylvia Plath entitled “The Silent Woman.” Essentially, it calls into question the entire undertaking of biography asserting that each biography is really one version of a life. By extension, we might apply this to memoir as well. Even though a memoir is a form of autobiography, it is still one version told through the lens of the memoirist. Thus, truth is a somewhat slippery fish in this regard.

1
Reply
Tiffany

Hmm, I was always taught and beleive, Biographies are only “Written” once, and memiors are about events that happened, and you can have a million memiors but only one full story of your life (biography).

Interesting.

0
BobQuestion author

@Tiffany, that is how I look at it as well with the exception that the autobiography is written once, but biographies are written by others and therefore could be slanted based on the research of the authors.

0
BobQuestion author

“The Silent Woman” is now on my TBR list. 🙂

1
Tiffany

That’s very true Bob.

0
Kevin

@Bob it’s not too long. It appeared originally in sections in the NYer. Always enjoy Malcolm’s writing.

1
Paula

Depends on the memoir.

0
Reply
Freda

Love them…

1
Reply
Jamie

I go with Paula. It depends–I read two recently, one by Barbara Eden and the other by Ann-Margret. The first I loved, the second I hated.

2
Reply
Jeanette

I didn’t realize Barbara Eden had one. I’ll have to check it out.

0
Jamie

I think it’s great. Granted she collaborated with someone, but I still think her honest voice, with an unglamourized feel to her story, comes right through. So many actors are not honest about their lives.

1
Jeanette

Thanks for the recommendation! ?

0
Sarah

I had to read The Glass Castle in high school, and I loved it so much. Such an emotional story, but it was amazing ?☺️

2
Reply
BobQuestion author

The Glass Castle is in my library – to be read. I need to add it to the queue soon. They’ve made a movie based on the book.

1
Sarah

@Bob they had better not ruin it in the movie. The trailer I saw made it look like a perfect relationship between father and daughter. I wanted to hurl my phone at the wall. The whole book is almost the exact opposite. ?

1
BobQuestion author

OK. No spoilers. 🙂 Haha!

1
Germaine

I like them.

1
Reply
Cindy

Love them

1
Reply
Holly

The Glass Castle – one of my top three ❤️?

2
Reply
Gail

Mine too

0
Gail

Love them

1
Reply
Wendy

Love them…they can be so inspirational as it is real life not just fantasy and if they can overcome…then there is hope for me

1
Reply
Sandrine

Love them. I read so many biographies too!

2
Reply
Kristyn

Love them!!

1
Reply
Athena

Depends…

1
Reply
Clarence

Same here

0
Amanda

Not my thing

0
Reply
Bill

It all depends on who it is. As to be someone that I like, or have an interest in. Don Rickles was fantastic. Laughed the whole read.

2
Reply
Gail

Read Tim Conway’s book. Hahaha

1
Bill

I’ll have to check that out. Thank you.

0
Gail

Called “What’s So Funny?”

1
Bill

Thank you.

1
Sandra

Love them!

1
Reply
Paula

Depending on who it is and why it was written. Betty White had me in tears laughing and sadness

2
Reply
Sabrina

Not my thing. The word “I” is typically used so much that it becomes annoying to read.

1
Reply
Paula

Isn’t that the word you use to describe yourself ?

0
Sabrina

It is, and I do understand why it is necessary. But it still annoys me. Just my own personal quirk.

0
Tiffany

I am the same way, Sabrina. I found writing my own story was difficult because i do not prefer first person in any manner!

0
Deborah

Depends on the person writing it.

2
Reply
Ella

Depends on whose it is

1
Reply
Jeanette

I’d say like them. I read them as they catch my eye. My first love will always be fiction though.

1
Reply
Gail

Image may contain: 1 person, text
0
Reply
Book

I enjoyed the new Alec Baldwin memoir

1
Reply
Tona

Depends

1
Reply
Gail

Depends on who the book is about,

3
Reply
Rycj

IMHO?

Image may contain: 7 people, people smiling
2
Reply
Jennifer

I am not a big fan

0
Reply
Ken

I can read them. But not a fan.

0
Reply
Tammy

I’ve read and enjoyed a few, but I usually prefer to wait until I can find out how it ends, I prefer biographies.

1
Reply
Lesley

It depends on who wrote them.

0
Reply
Jennifer

I am not big on celebrity memoirs because it was probably ghost written most times.

0
Reply
Kevin

I agree. Letters and memoirs of writers engage me the most.

0
Leave a Answer Cancel

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Loading Please wait
Log in
Register
Categories
  • get the book
  • questionnaire
  • recommend
  • review
Genres
animal art biography business chick lit classics comics contemporary cookbooks crime detective fantasy fiction gay and lesbian graphic novel historical fiction history horror humor and comedy kids languages manga memoir music mystery nonfiction novel paranormal philosophy poetry psychology religies religion romance scary science science fiction self help spirituality sports suspense thriller travel young adult young adults
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions

2019 © TheBookSwarm