Obviously at times it’s a Difficult read but the way I look at it is these people had to go through it, I only have to read it and get some understanding of what they went through. It wouldn’t be fair to you to say it’s anything but, however it is a love story so it’s heartwarming also. X
Just finished it the other day (devoured it in hours) it’s harrowing but gripping. It was originally going to be a screenplay so it has a pacey flow that makes it easy to read.
I totally agree. The writing is quite basic. I thought it was good but not brilliant. It ended a little strangely like in a rush to tell the last parts of the story.
It’s ok. Feels like a big rush at the end to get loads of facts out. I understand it started out as a screen play and I think that it is more appropriate genre. Good, moving story though
I’ve read it. I think it was a poorly written version of what could have been a brilliant book. The writer is a screenwriter, not an author, and I think it showed. The story was pretty vague and woolly, she didn’t do the people it was about justice. I came away without any real idea of how each scenario truly made them feel.
I agree. Did not like the style of writing & to be honest I doubted whether the story was accurate. I’ve read much better holaucast books than this. Can’t understand how it has rated so high. Too much hype
You said the story was vague and woolly – mg question is did you feel like the stakes were high for the characters? Obviously given the genre I assume the characters have a lot to lose but did that come across in the novel, or were the stakes also a bit vague?
Well, given what we know about the Holocaust, I don’t think that you could read a book about internment in a concentration camp without knowing the inherent danger the prisoners were in. So it’s hard to read it without just automatically knowing what they faced. I found the relationship between Lale and his personal guard quite unbelievable, given what he “got away” with doing.
Read it as a book club read. Most enjoyed it. I couldn’t finish it. I believe all these stories should be told but I have read far better written accounts.
Was just going to post about this book. Literally bought three days ago and it’s the most unbelievable read- finished it in threes sittings. Very haunting but touching
I think the story felt slightly emotionless in parts because the characters just weren’t able to ‘feel’ anymore and this was by intent. Certainly the main character was described as quite distant by his son in his personal conclusion but it’s hardly surprising considering what his father endured. It was true to life and an accurate account of the slightly skewed memories of the main character- just added to the authenticity in my view
@Caroline i agree that is certainly part of of it, the ending seemed contrived rather than realistic. i think i also felt the writing was immature although telling an important story, they didnt quite manage to find the right balance between retelling a story and not making it too horrific to read, which it obviously was to live…. Thank you for helping me find the words to describe how I feel about the book.
Regardless of peoples opinions its still a true story of the horrors that went on. It is incredibly hard to portray just how bad it all was when writing someone elses story. I think the author did very well and gave the man whos story it was her upmost respect and gratitude for opening up to her
@Rebecca yes it is well worth a read if you read it you will see why give a break think Mills and Boon to lift me out of awful things people suffered in the awful war .
I really enjoyed it. Quite harrowing in parts but that’s to be expected. It’s got a nice ending and is a true story.
I’ve just picked it up but I don’t really read true story’s they upset me too much but I thought I’d give it a try Thankyou x
Obviously at times it’s a Difficult read but the way I look at it is these people had to go through it, I only have to read it and get some understanding of what they went through. It wouldn’t be fair to you to say it’s anything but, however it is a love story so it’s heartwarming also. X
Maybe if you know they upset you Rebecca it might be just as well that you don’t? Just be prepared x
I know they upset me but I’d like to get some insight on what people went through it’s such a awful thing that happened x
@Rebecca so true x
Not the best ww2 book I’ve read but it was ok.
I’ve never read any others but Thankyou
What’s some that you do recommend if you don’t mind me asking? I read the nightingale but am looking for more ww2 reads.
@Kristal try Gertruda’s Oath. Or Once We Were Brothers. Different stories and interesting.
I enjoyed it.
Oh I can’t wait to read it I’ve heard a lot of mixed feelings about it so it was putting me off x
Just finished it the other day (devoured it in hours) it’s harrowing but gripping. It was originally going to be a screenplay so it has a pacey flow that makes it easy to read.
Thankyou I’ll probably have it read in a few hours aha
Very good
The story itself is good and I think needs to be told but the writing is lack luster and was kind of dissaponting
Thankyou x
I totally agree. The writing is quite basic. I thought it was good but not brilliant. It ended a little strangely like in a rush to tell the last parts of the story.
It’s ok. Feels like a big rush at the end to get loads of facts out. I understand it started out as a screen play and I think that it is more appropriate genre. Good, moving story though
Fantastic!
Thankyou!
Very good
Very good
Very good
Yes amazing
Yes it’s very good.
I havent read it yet. Ive heard mixed reviews.
I’ve heard a lot of mixed reviews aswell, I’ve just started it and it’s okay so far x
@Rebecca keep me posted.
@Debbie I’ll let you know what I think of it x
@Rebecca thank you. ?
It’s really good I recommend it x
@Rebecca thanks for letting me know.
@Debbie you’re welcome x
Very special book, especially as only at the end did I learn it was a true story
Outstanding
excellent
Outstanding a book one must ????? read.
Brilliant
Yes amazing story couldn’t put it down
It’s a really good book. And it’s very closely based on true events. So that made it even better.
Yes
Excellent
I want it but amazon release date not until 9/4
I picked it up at Asda x
What is that?
British supermarket.
Just finished it last night. And I loved it.
Superb read
Great read!
Wonderful book
Really moving and it’s a true story too
Yep, heart breaking but a great read.
I can’t wait to read it!
Brilliant
Very good
Great read
I’ve read it. I think it was a poorly written version of what could have been a brilliant book. The writer is a screenwriter, not an author, and I think it showed. The story was pretty vague and woolly, she didn’t do the people it was about justice. I came away without any real idea of how each scenario truly made them feel.
I agree. Did not like the style of writing & to be honest I doubted whether the story was accurate. I’ve read much better holaucast books than this. Can’t understand how it has rated so high. Too much hype
I agree Corinne!
i feel bad giving a negative review of a book that everyone is raving about. But best to be honest
How are the stakes?
I’m not sure what you mean, Ameera.
You said the story was vague and woolly – mg question is did you feel like the stakes were high for the characters? Obviously given the genre I assume the characters have a lot to lose but did that come across in the novel, or were the stakes also a bit vague?
Well, given what we know about the Holocaust, I don’t think that you could read a book about internment in a concentration camp without knowing the inherent danger the prisoners were in. So it’s hard to read it without just automatically knowing what they faced. I found the relationship between Lale and his personal guard quite unbelievable, given what he “got away” with doing.
Thanks! I still plan on reading it, but having an analysis and an honest review help
Currently reading it and love it so far.
So moving x
Excellent.
Brilliant book
I wouldn’t say it was brilliant more ok. I thought it lacked emotion.
Good book
FANTASTIC!
Really good, definitely worth a read ??
I liked it was a good read.
Enjoyed reading it
On my tbr list
Just bought the hardback…surprised how thin it felt. Am waiting to read it as looks like I could get through it in a day or so!
I’ve started even though I bought it with the intention to read it on my commute to and from work x
I was disappointed
Read it as a book club read. Most enjoyed it. I couldn’t finish it. I believe all these stories should be told but I have read far better written accounts.
Was just going to post about this book. Literally bought three days ago and it’s the most unbelievable read- finished it in threes sittings. Very haunting but touching
Yes. Glad I read it.
Yes, excellent :
I think the story felt slightly emotionless in parts because the characters just weren’t able to ‘feel’ anymore and this was by intent. Certainly the main character was described as quite distant by his son in his personal conclusion but it’s hardly surprising considering what his father endured. It was true to life and an accurate account of the slightly skewed memories of the main character- just added to the authenticity in my view
Felt the same…
Excellent read x
Excellent
In my opinion it was very poorly written so disappointed with it was so glad I got it free from library and didn’t have to pay for it
Amazing!
Fantastic
Amazing but v sad xx
Amazing! A must read.
Outstanding
Enjoyed it. Have recommended to a few friends
I’m enjoying it so far
Loved it
Great book xx
really good – totally recommend
I am 87% through it and have loved it all so far!
I’d say this book is a must read, go for it!
I’ve started it and I’m liking it so far Thankyou x
Read it in 2 days last week and loved it … inspiring that love could find a way in that hateful place x
Oh I can’t wait to finish it I’m only a couple of chapters in x
A worthwhile read. I agree with Emma’s observations.
Where did you get it?
I got it from Asda
What is adds?
Asda
@Debbie it’s a supermarket but it’s also on amazon for £6 x
So not in the states?
oh I no I’m not from the states x
England?
@Debbie yes
Nice
@Debbie are you from the states?
Excellent book
Rilliant
good account, but felt it was lacking something i can’t quite put my finger on.
If I was going to be picky I felt the end was a little rushed & you didn’t get a sense of how long it took for them to find each other??
@Caroline i agree that is certainly part of of it, the ending seemed contrived rather than realistic. i think i also felt the writing was immature although telling an important story, they didnt quite manage to find the right balance between retelling a story and not making it too horrific to read, which it obviously was to live…. Thank you for helping me find the words to describe how I feel about the book.
Yes I do agree with your comments
I’m reading it its good!
Fantastic!
Awesome
Yes and it is a great reaf
Fantastic. Couldn’t believe its a true story
Brilliant
Very good. Just finished reading it
I haven’t read it yet. But it’s coming to me in September.
Yes v good
Fabulous book xxx
Its beautiful
I was a bit disappointed with it to be honest as I expected to love it. ?
Amazing book!
Loved it
Yes
Excellent
Yep 🙂
It is so good! Definitely read it
I enjoyed it
Absolutely
Made me cry multiple times
Half way through on audio and I’m really enjoying it
I’m enjoying it so far aswelll.
I liked it
There’s a lot of mixed opinions on this book
There are
A must read. I found it fascinating ??
I thought it was an excellent book x
It’s incredible x
Loved it
I’m just starting it. Have to admit it hasn’t grabbed me so far
Not Bad but not as good as all the hyoe
Yes
Very good. Made me cry.
It’s on my list.
Excellent
Not as good as it could have been
Slow to start but got me hooked later on
Very good I recommend it especially as it’s a true story and not another historical fiction holocaust book
I read Holocaust book
Currently reading it
It is worth reading . It is an interesting story and is written from a different prospective from a lot of holocaust books .
It’s a true story.
@Vanessa I lnow
I’m really enjoying it Thankyou
Reading now love it
excellent bookl
I’m really enjoying it
Brilliant book
Its very good
I thought it was an excellent book BUT there was something missing in the way it was written and I can’t quite put my finger on it !
I think I know what you mean im only have way through myself though
Very unsophisticated writing. Completely lacked the emotion it should have had
I agree with that totally
A wonderful read is The Fiddle
Also a true story
Written by Natalie Cummings
Great story
fantastic but keep those tissues at hand ?
I was reading it on my way to work and had to stop before I cried on the bus
I read a sample on my kindle the other day
One to download properly I think
I recently read it and really enjoyed it it does give a different perspective on the holocaust
Regardless of peoples opinions its still a true story of the horrors that went on. It is incredibly hard to portray just how bad it all was when writing someone elses story. I think the author did very well and gave the man whos story it was her upmost respect and gratitude for opening up to her
I agree with this
No was going to read it next as have the book but after reading Arlette story what great book that was .
Oh i think I’ll try that one aswell x
@Rebecca yes it is well worth a read if you read it you will see why give a break think Mills and Boon to lift me out of awful things people suffered in the awful war .
@Angeline I’ll see if I can get it some time this week Thankyou
Think it was 99p on Kindle not sure if still it’s