Will finish listening to it this week, probably on Tuesday. Heartbreaking story, but so well written! The BITNB PGH Meet-Up is reading it for our April book discussion. If you’re in or near Pittsburgh come join us, Wednesday, April 10th 6:30pm to dine, then discussion and book chat 7:00-9:00pm. Meeting Room at Panera at the Galleria in Mt. Lebanon.
I liked it but as I told someone, ‘I liked it enough to finish it but not enough to recommend it’…. the author’s style of writing is very choppy and there were parts i had to go back and say ‘wait, what did I miss?’
Jill Schneider Wilger I was meh about Lilac Girls. Thank goodness books are a matter of opinion! 🙂 The Nightingale is another one of my favorite historical fiction novels…and a must read.
I thought it was a good book and even though some say there are historical inaccuracies, it seems to have a parallel story line to others I’ve read. You’d have to make your own judgment afterwards.
Yes, it’s worth it!! The writing was simple & lacked depth, but it was a beautiful story about love and triumph in the midst of tragedy. I found the afterward by Lale & Gita’s son very moving. I read it quickly in one 3 hour sitting…
Very superficial compared to many other accounts of life in a concentration camp. It’s a nice read, but I would look to other books to give you the reality.
Yes! It’s really good.
Good story, but I didn’t care for the authors style of writing.
I thought it was a ((disturbingly)) good book.
Good story, but the author didn’t do it justice, nor did she include a list of references (which made me really stabby ).
Kelly Roder stabby?
I really liked it.
Yes, it was good.
I enjoyed it very much.
I hear they are making a movie of it
Yes. I loved the audio version
Will finish listening to it this week, probably on Tuesday. Heartbreaking story, but so well written! The BITNB PGH Meet-Up is reading it for our April book discussion. If you’re in or near Pittsburgh come join us, Wednesday, April 10th 6:30pm to dine, then discussion and book chat 7:00-9:00pm. Meeting Room at Panera at the Galleria in Mt. Lebanon.
@Maureen thank you for posting this!! I was looking for this! I plan on joining y’all…. ?
@Karen we will sincerely look forward to meeting you! ? ?
I thought the writing was quite flat.
Very good book ?
I really enjoyed it
Enjoyed it. Very quick read.
I really liked it.
Pretty good! Very quick read.
I liked it but as I told someone, ‘I liked it enough to finish it but not enough to recommend it’…. the author’s style of writing is very choppy and there were parts i had to go back and say ‘wait, what did I miss?’
@Jen yes! So many better ones out there. I’m surprised of all the hype.
@Lynn 100% agree!
I couldn’t get through it.
I liked it!
It was ok, not my fave WWII historical fiction
I thought it had potential but was very slow
I thought it had potential but was very slow
I enjoyed it
I thought it was poorly written and didn’t finish. Lilac Girls was wonderful, if you haven’t read that and are interested in WWII fiction.
Jill Schneider Wilger I was meh about Lilac Girls. Thank goodness books are a matter of opinion! 🙂 The Nightingale is another one of my favorite historical fiction novels…and a must read.
I loved it personally and was totally worth it IMO
Great book
I enjoyed it.
Yes, I liked it!!!
didn’t connect with the writing
I just picked up at a yard sale.
Yes
I loved
Didn’t love the writing but enjoyed the book overall.
It’s a very good book, but there are a lot of historical inaccuracies.
@Kelly ie?
Interesting book, but for a true story, it’s hard to believe at some points
Well written historical fiction to me.
I thought it was meh….
I loved it!
I liked We Were The Lucky Ones better.
I thought it was a good book and even though some say there are historical inaccuracies, it seems to have a parallel story line to others I’ve read. You’d have to make your own judgment afterwards.
Loved it!!
I loved it personally and was totally worth it IMO
Listening to this right now. Every time I read a Holocaust novel, I get so angry that this was a real thing that happened to people. #NeverAgain
Good story, but I just did not like her writing.
Kristin, same here. Maybe if it was classified as a memoir instead of historic fiction? I can’t quite pinpoint what I don’t like about it.
@Kristin ditto. She’s a screenplay writer and it showed.
So good
One of my favorites from last year.
Loved it! Read it in one evening- very easy to read book (outside of the horrific events that occur)
Just ok.
I liked it.
Loved it!
Yes, it’s worth it!! The writing was simple & lacked depth, but it was a beautiful story about love and triumph in the midst of tragedy. I found the afterward by Lale & Gita’s son very moving. I read it quickly in one 3 hour sitting…
YES! finished it last month and already planning to read it again
So good! Quick read
I thought it was good
Yes! Loved this book so much❤️
loved it!
Loved it finished reading in a day and a half
Yes, yes! Read it. Worth the time and from a different perspective!
Yesyesyes!
Yes – great book
Absolutely!
It was awesome!!
Wonderful
I loved it!
So good!
I finished it a few days ago. It was well worth the read!
100 % yes
Great book:)
Yes
Oh yes!!!
Yes
Yes!
Meh. I wanted to love it but I just don’t think it was that well written.
I really liked it – quick but tough read!!
loved it!
Very good book! Highly recommend
So good
Oh. My. Gosh. SO GOOD!!!!
I thought it was okay. Great story, but I didn’t like her writing style.
It’s not as good as Lilac Girls- but worth your time.
I liked it. I’ve read a lot of WWII books about concentration camps and found this to be very interesting
To me it was not a nobel prize winner but I enjoyed it a lot
I liked it..it is a story that needed to be told.
Yes!
It was just meh for me. There are so many better Holocaust books, IMO.
I really loved it.
Loved it! ❤️❤️❤️?
Great read
Loved it, a favorite
Yes, definitely. Just remember it is a novel, not historical fiction. A great read.
Very superficial compared to many other accounts of life in a concentration camp. It’s a nice read, but I would look to other books to give you the reality.
A better romance, written by survivor with more realistic details is, for one, “I will Plant you a Lilac Tree.”
Good, quick read.