TheBookSwarm
Ask Question

Do you prefer books to be realistic or fantastic?

Do you prefer books to be realistic or fantastic?

Paula #questionnaire #fantasy

10
Reply

62 Answers

Jeff

I don’t mind real-world fantastic (ie, there may be creatures, but it is overall real-world ish), but I draw the line around orcs and swords and mages and stuff.

2
Reply
Teresa

Realistic

1
Reply
Zack

Can’t decide? Both

1
Reply
Vicki

Depends entirely on mood of the moment..and if it sounds like a good story.

1
Reply
Patricia

either – just have to be well written and hold my attention

2
Reply
Abubakar

Sometimes real and the other time fantasy.

1
Reply
Mireille

Fantastic please

1
Reply
Csilla

Fantastic

1
Reply
Sandy

Realistic mostly

1
Reply
Oscar

I demand that nonfiction books to be realistic (tongue firmly in cheek). The others are free to take me where they will.

4
Reply
Vicki

Yes, I expect there to be a distinct line between fiction and nonfiction. I also tend to look for end notes and a bibliography with most modern nonfiction. I want some documentation and other titles to explore.

3
Oscar

You must love Bill Bryson, man loves to site his sources. On a tangent, I’m reading The Mother Tongue: English and how it got that way by the professor.

2
PaulaQuestion author

I love Bill Bryson. A Walk in the Woods remains a favorite NF. And funny as hell

1
Vicki

As a matter of fact, I DO love BB. His printed work is funny, but his audios make me laugh out loud. Something about his delivery..

1
Oscar

@Paula In a Sunburned Country is also very good. I’ve also seen this book under the title of Australia.

2
Vicki

@Oscar That audio is wonderful too.

1
Oscar

@Vicki I really should spend more time with audio books.

0
Vicki

I’m working on that…I don’t hear well, so have avoided them for myself. When the kids were younger, it was just too noisy for me to listen attentively, as I had to contend with them AND the audio, and the doorbell, or the phone, etc. Putting on headphones was an open invitation for them all to NEED me, NOW,

1
Oscar

@Vicki How I miss my kids when they were little. Ages 4 through 8 were my very best times in my life. When I picture my kids, I see them that age. Don’t miss the noise too much, though. What I miss is the hanging out with them, doing nothing in particular, eating ice cream, giggling uncontrollably, or my favorite pastime with them was: What is another word for? Another word for red, or smile, house. Made them think.

1
Boglárka

Fantastic

1
Reply
Gary

Realistic

1
Reply
Tija

Realistic. I have a couple of favourite paranormal horrors that are novels but are semi realistic. It could happen…but probably not…but ya never know ?

1
Reply
Jeannie

I love both

1
Reply
Tilottama

Both

1
Reply
Siti

Both in order to make sense.

2
Reply
Rohen

Realistically Fantastic! 😀

2
Reply
Lorrea

Realistic

1
Reply
Colleen

Historical Fiction !

1
Reply
Hoogeveen

I prefer realistic

1
Reply
Traci

Depends on the story. I want stories to be internally consistent with the world they’re set in.

2
Reply
Melissa

I read mostly books on history so realistic but fiction books I prefer them fantastic.

2
Reply
Chirag

I wish life was as realistic as a biography, and as fantastic as a science fiction. ?

1
Gregory

It’s best when you keep a nice balance between the two. I lean more towards the realistic. I am not a fan of pure fantasy or heavy science fiction. The only Tolkien that I have read is The Hobbit which rated a mild “meh”. Sci-fi just about the hardware bores me. I love the Dune series by Frank Herbert because the characters are never upstaged by the sci-fi aspects.

2
Reply
Melissa

Realistic

1
Reply
Amanda

Fantasy based in reality.

2
Reply
Holly

Realistic

1
Reply
Tammy

Realistic

1
Reply
Tracey

I’ll take either

1
Reply
Gilmar

Can it be both genders? I write fantastic literature of horror, adventure and fantasy, but I really like Gabriel Garcia Marques. His literature can be classified as fantastic realism. The book One Hundred Years of Solitude is one of my favorites.

3
Reply
Chris

Realistic

1
Reply
Paula

Fantastic, even if I’m reading a book based on a real individual, I like facts but they can be a bit fantastic☺️?

2
Reply
Kris

Realistic.

1
Reply
Linda

I love like both?

1
Reply
Michele

In the true sense of each word, I think that a good book can be both realistic and fantastic at the same time.

4
Reply
Oscar

We need a word for that middle ground.

0
Michele

@Oscar exactly.

1
Oscar

@Michele magical realism. Not exactly a word, but there’s a term for it.

1
Michele

@Oscar I think of fantastic as being incredible or superb… which could be any book, realistic or not.

1
Oscar

@Michele I do, too. Magical realism is the closest I could find. We still need a word for that middle ground.

0
Clara

How about spellbinding………….?

2
Michele

@Clara I like it!

0
Pevensie

Fantastic.

1
Reply
Tamari

Fantastic – otherwise the mc might be dead by the first chapter. Lol.

1
Reply
Sudarshan

realistic

1
Reply
Sudarshan

or some where between the line like animal farm

1
Reply
Janie

I enjoy both. I like fantasy stories that could possibly happen.

1
Reply
Ghel

Something in between ?

0
Reply
Ray

I like both. Depends on my mood.

0
Reply
Rob

I don’t know about you, but I’d much rather a book I read be fantastic rather than terrible. Now that I’ve gotten the smart a** out of my system, both. I enjoy grounded fantastic.

1
Reply
Oscar

“smart a** out of my system” this deserves a like.

1
Courtney

Both

0
Reply
John

If the background is supposed to be real (like historical fiction and forensic crime) I demand it be realistic.

0
Reply
Leave a Answer Cancel

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Loading Please wait
Log in
Register
Categories
  • get the book
  • questionnaire
  • recommend
  • review
Genres
animal art biography business chick lit classics comics contemporary cookbooks crime detective fantasy fiction gay and lesbian graphic novel historical fiction history horror humor and comedy kids languages manga memoir music mystery nonfiction novel paranormal philosophy poetry psychology religies religion romance scary science science fiction self help spirituality sports suspense thriller travel young adult young adults
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions

2019 © TheBookSwarm