TheBookSwarm
Ask Question

Debating..The Woman in the Window, Behind Closed Doors or The Woman in Cabin 10?

Debating….The Woman in the Window, Behind Closed Doors or The Woman in Cabin 10???

Noelle #review

10
Reply

60 Answers

Sheryl

Behind closed doors!!!

1
Reply
Arielle

I’ve only read the first two and I preferred Behind Closed Doors

1
Reply
Michelle

In the Window

1
Reply
Eden

Behind Closed Doors

1
Reply
Sandra

BCD,

1
Reply
Leigh

Behind closed doors. Have the other 2 on my tbr list…

1
Reply
Jodi

You can’t go wrong with any of these… All great

2
Reply
Amy

Behind Closed Doors

1
Reply
Laura

Window

1
Reply
Hazel

Behind closed doors!

1
Reply
Nicole

Behind Closed Doors is the only one of the three I’ve read. I loved it and couldn’t put it down. Read it in a day.

1
Reply
Nicole

Behind Closed Doors. I thought The Woman in Cabin Ten was terrible and The Woman in the Window was just okay.

3
Reply
Lynn

Cabin 10

1
Reply
Monica

I read the first two. Woman in the Window took forever to get into. Behind Closed Doors was great and I really loved it from beginning to end

1
Reply
Megan

Behind Closed Doors, 100%

1
Reply
Zaynab

Behind closed doors *shivers*

1
Reply
Donna

Sorry, but I did not like the Woman in Cabin 10, it was lame.

1
Reply
Ava

Behind Closed Doors is a must read if you like psychological thrillers! Second to that I would recommend the Woman in the window, my only disappointment with the latter is that the story line drags on until you’re about 75% in; then it really gets exciting.

2
Reply
Rita

Cabin 10

1
Reply
Katie

Behind Closed Doors

1
Reply
Mj

Behind Closed Doors just because I havent read the two 😀

1
Reply
Lee

Behind Closed Doors

1
Reply
Jennifer

All 3 wonderful books!!

1
Reply
Jennifer

And you would probably love sometimes I lie by Alice feeney

1
Reply
NoelleQuestion author

Thank you! I added it to my TBR list.

1
Jennifer

Its great! If you like psycological thrillers you’ll like our book blog. http://www.twogirlsandabookobsession.com/

1
Jennifer

Hope you like it!

1
Jennifer

The Woman in the Window.

1
Reply
Johnna

I loved the two I read, behind and the woman, I think it depends on what you are in the mood for. If a slow start, but amazing story once it goes, that’s truly chilling, I say the woman, if more brutal intensity, I sat behind. 🙂

1
Reply
NoelleQuestion author

Thank you for the feedback!

1
Dallas

Window

1
Reply
Brenda

I’ve read woman in cabin 10 (it was what sparked my interest for psychological thrillers) but I thought it was ok. Behind closed doors was sooo good!!!! I have a signed woman at window on my tbr list. At the end of the day, everyone has their own opinions (which is great!) so I don’t think you can go wrong with either one!!! I actually look on goodreads and put them in ascending order in terms of their ratings and start with the lowest and move higher!

1
Reply
NoelleQuestion author

I never knew you could put them in order of their rating! I’ll have to do that.

0
Brenda

@Noelle Hi Noelle! I don’t think you can put them in order. I just look up each book individually and note the rating. I often have to do this when I get a large-ish stack of library books and can’t decide on which one to start with. I feel like if you start off with the best/most hyped/best reviews, the rest of them aren’t as good!

1
NoelleQuestion author

@Brenda I just looked and on Goodreads you can put your to read list in average rank order. Great idea to start with the lowest rated ones!

0
Brenda

@Noelle That’s even better! lol!!

1
Nicole

I’ve read all of them- you can’t go wrong with any of them!

1
Reply
Annette

They all sound good?

1
Reply
Jessica

Behind Closed Doors over Cabin 10. Haven’t read Woman in the Window yet.

2
Reply
Nicole

I agree.

2
Ashley

Cabin 10

2
Reply
Justine

Loved Behind Closed Doors but The Woman in Cabin 10 was one of my least favorite books of 2017.

1
Reply
Mamey

Behind Closed Doors

2
Reply
Charlotte

They are all good but I liked Woman in the Window the best.

1
Reply
Donna

Behind Closed Doors

2
Reply
Sammantha

Behind Closed Doors ?

3
Reply
Carolynn

Read all 3 and Behind closed doors, then woman in the window then cabin 10

2
Reply
Pam

All good

2
Reply
Becki

The woman in cabin 10 was ok. Nothing GREAT. I haven’t read the other 2 yet.

1
Reply
Amber

Any…

1
Reply
Ginger

Behind closed doors

3
Reply
Komal

I have read The Woman in Cabin 10 and Behind closed doors. Both of them were average in my opinion. Haven’t yet read The Woman in the window. Looking forward!

1
Reply
Sara

Behind Closed Doors was better than Woman In cabin 10. Woman in the Window is still on my TBR list.

1
Reply
Amy

I enjoyed all of the them!

1
Reply
Diane

I’ve read all three, Woman in the Window is the best of the three

1
Reply
Nilsa

I just finished Behind Closed Doors and couldn’t stop reading until finished! It is gooood!

1
Reply
Kathie

Read a Woman in Cabin 10 last, just eh

1
Reply
Casey

Behind closed doors is a fast read. Well I read it in 4hrs it was so good.

1
Reply
Jasna

All 3 were 3 stars for me

1
Reply
Shonnel

all 3 are really good !! cause they’re similar

1
Reply
Leave a Answer Cancel

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Loading Please wait
Log in
Register
Categories
  • get the book
  • questionnaire
  • recommend
  • review
Genres
animal art biography business chick lit classics comics contemporary cookbooks crime detective fantasy fiction gay and lesbian graphic novel historical fiction history horror humor and comedy kids languages manga memoir music mystery nonfiction novel paranormal philosophy poetry psychology religies religion romance scary science science fiction self help spirituality sports suspense thriller travel young adult young adults
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions

2019 © TheBookSwarm