TheBookSwarm
Ask Question

Anyone read Born a Crime by Trevor Noah? I’m not sure how I feel about it, or him. ??

Anyone read Born a Crime by Trevor Noah? I’m not sure how I feel about it, or him. ??

Kim #review

36
Reply

113 Answers

Lanie

I enjoyed it, but I also like him.

5
Reply
KimQuestion author

@Lanie he kind of seems like a bit of a dick though. ?

1
Lanie

@Kim Idk if I’d like him in real life, but I think he’s funny and really cute.

4
Erina

Love him and the book

5
Reply
Karol

I listened to it twice in the last 6 months. I loved his insights and perspectives. He has lived a very different life than I have.

5
Reply
KimQuestion author

@Karol absolutely. And I see his point on many things. Still, I’m not sure if I like him.

0
Karol

He did some crazy stuff. I believe he grew up in survival mode, trying to fit in and be accepted and not end up dead.

5
Kelly

Not a fan of him, his book, the audio book, or his comedy. I wanted to be after all I heard here, but not my cup of tea.

3
Reply
Jessica

@Kelly Fair enough. I’ve felt the same about books/authors that others have raved over. It happens ??‍♀️

4
Jessica

Yes, and I loved it. His experience and perspective are so unique.

6
Reply
KimQuestion author

@Jessica agree on the experience and perspective.

1
Whitney

It was fine. The pooping on the newspaper and Hitler dancing bits made it worthwhile.

4
Reply
KimQuestion author

@Whitney I don’t like that he feels no remorse for setting that house on fire!

0
Whitney

I’d forgotten that. Yeah, I suspect he’s not a guy I would like.

1
Megan

I’m listening to the audiobook (my first ever!) and I really enjoy it so far. I’m about halfway through.

2
Reply
Leah

I loved the book but I already loved him.

5
Reply
Melissa

I loved it. I thought he seemed like a genuine human being who endured a lot as a child. He may not have always been perfect, but none of us are, especially as children.

13
Reply
Jessica

@Melissa Yes, a lot of honesty there!

0
Melissa

I really enjoyed the audiobook. His accents are amazing!

1
Reply
Melissa

Love him! Loved his book!

0
Reply
Theresa

❤❤ him! I listened to the audiobook, he narrated.

0
Reply
Kaci

I read a whole lot of books last year and that book stuck with me the most of all the books I read. There are several pages/stories that impacted me quite a bit.

3
Reply
Karol

His statement on regret blew me away!

0
Kristin

Loved it! What is it about him that you don’t like…or is it the way he writes?

2
Reply
KimQuestion author

@Kristin I’m not sure yet. I need to mull it over and get back to y’all.

0
Sue

Loved the book. I learned a LOT.

3
Reply
KimQuestion author

@Sue I did too!

0
Brittany

The book totally wasn’t what I was expecting but I absolutely loved it. I think he is just amazing

4
Reply
Lisa

LOVED IT. If you’d like a visual – here’s a clip from a visit he recorded to his childhood home and with his grandmother.

4
Reply
Cathy

Yes. I listened to the audio book, and it was my favorite book of last year. Love it! What gives you pause?

1
Reply
Kate

It’s a fave on this page. On my TBR list. You can check the search function for some more discussion if interested

0
Reply
Cindy

As a bi-racial woman, I relate closely with his perspectives on societal matters.

His comedy is a coping mechanism against systemic issues of racism, and it helps to have that release when faced with realities that often feel surreal.

If you don’t experience life through a similar lens, consider yourself privileged. I thought his Son of Patricia special was real, and hilarious!

19
Reply
Jeneffer

@Cindy ^^^ all the above and yes to Son of Patricia special

1
KimQuestion author

@Cindy I’ve never seen anything he’s done-comedy or anything. It was recommended by a friend who loaned it to me so I was like “what the hell, I love to read” and it sounded interesting. I learned a lot.

1
Cindy

@Kim Agreed, and I have not watched his show either, just the special on Netflix.

0
Cindy

@Jeneffer Tacos!

2
Jeneffer

@Cindy ?

0
KimQuestion author

@Cindy I haven’t even seen that. I’ll have to watch it.

1
Cindy

@Jeneffer I turned it on while organizing my daughter’s puzzles, and time flew by!

0
Jeneffer

I just love all of his work though- I was a very big of John stewart (I’m Gen X so John Stewart was a big deal in my day) but I had no idea how much better he would be – as a woman raising a bi-racial son he helps me to keep my privlage in check and have some hope for our future at the same time.

4
Susannah

Jeneffer Haslam Huge Jon Stewart fan here too so it took me a good year to warm up to Trevor Noah but I do adore him now.

1
Betsy

@Cindy I read it and thought, I could not imagine a life experience more different than my own and how remarkable that he’s thrived. I thinks it’s a common mistake not to recognize that it’s impossible to judge by a set of standards so unrelated to his life experience. Based on our country, I came from lower middle class whit America, but that it privileged beyond compare to apartheid South Africa.

1
Maureen

I read it, didn’t love it. I thought it was okay, but I really like his show.

0
Reply
Laura

I read and loved it

0
Reply
Leah

I didn’t know anything about him when I read it. I totally loved it!

0
Reply
Sharon

Loved it and love him!

0
Reply
Leslie

It was a great story to read–enjoyed it, kept me interested to see what happened next!

1
Reply
Lyndsay

It’s best on audio. I loved it.

0
Reply
Maheswari

I learnt a lot about apartheid from this book. I don’t necessarily listen to his show a lot but he is a good writer and the audio was amazing. One of the best audio books out there in my opinion.

4
Reply
Beverly

I was so excited when I received as a gift but I started it and had to stop for awhile and haven’t tried to finish it. I thought what I read so far was boring.

0
Reply
沙沙

Well, one less woman getting to know my boyfriend. ?

11
Reply
Sarah

I read it and thought it was interesting. I liked it (I do like him as a comedian also). I really liked the perspective of using language as an entry into people’s circle. Not a laugh out loud but I found the story interesting.

1
Reply
KimQuestion author

@Sarah I liked the language as entry a great idea as well. I hadn’t thought about it that wAy.

0
Carrie

I felt it was more of a memoir/love story to his mom. I loved it!

0
Reply
Samantha

I thought it was good but not what I was expecting. It gave insight on some cultures I hadn’t thought about a lot and so that was good….some funny stuff but I thought it would be more so. I learned a lot!

0
Reply
Claudia

I wasn’t really a follower of his and didn’t know that much about him prior to listening to the audiobook. I enjoyed it quite a bit, especially since it was read by him.

1
Reply
Sarah

Great book!

2
Reply
Stephanie

Love the book!

2
Reply
Linda

Loved it and love him! What an interesting insight into his upbringing!

2
Reply
Joi

Excellent?

0
Reply
Tesse

Loved it

0
Reply
Samantha

I listened it to. I like him 70% of the time and freely similarly about the book

0
Reply
Allyson

I loved it

0
Reply
Sue

If you are worried, he doesn’t hate white people because of apartheid. He does explain the system and shows how it damaged everyone including whites.

3
Reply
Kate

I thought it was fantastic. Also, damn he’s SMART. (I love Jon Stewart but he’s not an I-speak-5-languages kind of guy.)

5
Reply
Carolyn

@Kate same! And he’s amazing in person too. We saw him at the Chicago Theatre.

1
Bridget

Loved it! Definitely a great one to get on audiobook. Unique childhood growing up in South Africa

1
Reply
Dawn

I listened to it and found certain parts redundant. I dont remember specific examples, but there were some random facts he repeated multiple times unnecessarily. Like where a particular person was from, or seeing like that. I seemed to recall Everytime he referred to a particular person in his life, be said where they were from. For example, my best friend, Susie Q, from Austin, TX.

Just an editing detail, but an editing detail that annoyed me.

1
Reply
Cathleen

Loved it!! Love him!

0
Reply
Jodie

Yes and didn’t love it

0
Reply
Deanne

Slow in, fast out. Worth it.

0
Reply
Kim

I loved it.

0
Reply
Sarah

I’m not a big fan of his, but a lot of that has to do with how much I loved Jon Stewart. Those are big shoes to fill, and I couldn’t bring myself to watch the Daily Show after he left. However, I’ve seen clips here and there, and I didn’t find him particularly funny.

0
Reply
Gabriele

I loved it – a fresh perspective -and after reading his book,I appreciated him on the Daily Show even more…..

0
Reply
Julie

My daughter read it for school. She LOVED it – and she learned a lot, too.

2
Reply
Alison

I really enjoyed the book and his perspective about growing up in South Africa. I learned a lot.

2
Reply
Lauren

I love Trevor and loved his book as well.

0
Reply
Shereen

I listened thought it was great I heard they are making a movie too..

1
Reply
Susan

I loved the book and I lived in Apartheid South Africa. We need many more stories about those evil times to be told. Thanks Trevor Noah for telling it as you did.

7
Reply
Shannon

Just finished it. I liked it and his perspective as it is far different from how I grew up, but I am a fan of his already.

0
Reply
Lillian

I read it and enjoyed it. Definitely different than what I expected.

0
Reply
Ingeborg

Loved it

0
Reply
Jennifer

I liked it a lot.

0
Reply
Johanna

It was very good!! Funny, thought provoking and poignant. I listened to it on Audible and throughly enjoyed it!

0
Reply
Jennica

I loved it. I also love him. I listened to it on audible and it is my favorite audiobook to date.

1
Reply
Tylar

@Jennica I totally agree!

1
Erin

It was more poignant and acerbic than it was funny. I enjoyed it, but if people are going into the book looking for comedy it’s not really what that book is.

0
Reply
Sue

Love him and his book

0
Reply
Michele

I can’t stay up late enough to watch his show but the book was interesting as I knew so little about life in South Africa. I LOVE his mom!

3
Reply
Jennifer

I loved it!! I listened to the audio book and he was fantastic!

0
Reply
Beth

*love* him. I really want to read his book!

0
Reply
Lorraine

I found his life and background very interesting.

1
Reply
Paige

I read it before going to South Africa and ansolutely loved it.

1
Reply
Lori

Love him. Didn’t care for the stand up or book.

0
Reply
Wendy

Loved it!

0
Reply
Stacie

Listened to it on Audible and thought it was fantastic.

0
Reply
Laura

I did read it because we were planning to take our daughter to see him at s nearby casino. Wanted to learn more about him. He lived quite an interesting life. Born to a black woman and white man, he struggled with his race fitting in at school. The show at the casino was postponed due to him being on vocal rest. The new date is 5/10. Looking forward to it.

2
Reply
Liz

I loved the book, it was funny and really informative. It made me want to learn more about South Africa.

1
Reply
Diana

Eh. Some parts were interesting, but as a whole it wasn’t my favorite book. I never even heard of him or watched his show prior to reading the book

0
Reply
Mary

He is a good storyteller. He loves his mother. He is an intelligent, compassionate man who can see more than one side, and can understand how people are motivated. His characters are 3 dimensional. He has a sense of history, and how he lived through one of the great turning points for his country. He writes well, with some artistry. I like how he planted Easter eggs all through the book, then tied them all together at the end. For example, he starts his story talking about his mother and her obsessive insistence on religion and going to church, and how much that annoyed him. At the end of the book, he describes how her life was spared in a gunfight, apparently by Divine Intervention. The implied message is that his mothers faith was validated, despite Trevor’s dismissal of it. Mom was right.

9
Reply
Sarah

@Mary yes exactly!! What a wonderful review of the book

2
Mary

Another thing, I did my thesis on a development project in South Africa, and those slums in Lesotho and the Townships are some of the most difficult living conditions in the world. He talks about that in terms of what was negative, but also what was positive about that life. Nowadays we see the fame, the tuxedo, the smile, dimples, the British-y accent, but he is also the guy who sold pornography, drugs, and has a police record. He owns all that. I suspect there is another book coming about how he came to the realization that he could change his life. The pain of always being an outsider gave him the strength to walk away, into the unknown. He may not be a “nice guy.” I can’t imagine anyone trying to have a personal relationship with someone so busy and so successful, but he does have something to say. And he says it well.

2
Chris

Trevor Noah is articulate, intelligent and compassionate (and funny)>

1
Reply
Susan

I enjoyed the book more than expected. I don’t think of him as a writer but I was pleasantly surprised.

1
Reply
Tracy

Loved it. I listened to it; he is the reader and loved hearing his accent(s).

0
Reply
Jenny

loved it

0
Reply
Connie

I’m reading it now and loving it. He has had to face many struggles his entire life. Has a great sense of humor and the way he’s telling his story makes it enjoyable. I’m personally learning a lot about Africa

2
Reply
Jennifer

I loved it.

0
Reply
Crystal

Loved it

0
Reply
Robyn

Love him and his book

1
Reply
Patricia

I really enjoyed it. What’s your reservation?

1
Reply
KimQuestion author

@Patricia not sure yet. I’m mulling it over. Which in my opinion is something a good book will do – stay with you and make you think.

1
Patricia

@Kim hmmm. Ok

0
Leave a Answer Cancel

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Loading Please wait
Log in
Register
Categories
  • get the book
  • questionnaire
  • recommend
  • review
Genres
animal art biography business chick lit classics comics contemporary cookbooks crime detective fantasy fiction gay and lesbian graphic novel historical fiction history horror humor and comedy kids languages manga memoir music mystery nonfiction novel paranormal philosophy poetry psychology religies religion romance scary science science fiction self help spirituality sports suspense thriller travel young adult young adults
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions

2019 © TheBookSwarm