Am I the only one who did not love The Shack?
Am I the only one who did not love The Shack?
Related
19 answers
77 answers
163 answers
11 answers
49 answers
93 answers
31 answers
15 answers
46 answers
92 answers
Am I the only one who did not love The Shack?
Me either
Hated it
didnt get more than a few chapters.. hated it
Hated it. Threw it in the dumpster. Would not pass it on.
I’ve tried to read it three times and it never got better for me ?
Detested that book.
I got only halfway through. It just didn’t grab me.
I’m of the reverse opinion. I loved it. It was also the only book where I read the book, then saw the movie and found that the movie did the book justice.
It’s YUK
Couldn’t read it…
Won’t touch any book like it. Just can’t.
Um, I liked it but wouldn’t say it changed my life. It was okay.
I read “Love Shack” and I thought, “Who hates that song?!”. ?
??????
I put it down about half way through. It just didn’t resonate with me
Tried to read it this weekend and quickly decided it was not for me.
No, I didn’t care for it either. In fact, my Priest said he didn’t get anything out of it either.
Interesting….
I had a pastor colleague recommend it. But I didn’t like it well enough to keep a copy and probably won’t ever re-read it. As a preacher, however, I have to admit having quoted from it.
Couldn’t finish it. Life’s too short to Spend time with bad books.
Could anyone recommend a book or books for me to read as grandma to 12 yr old granddaughter book club? Thank you!
Yes, thanks!
I love Christian fiction but this book was disappointing. It could have been very healing but instead it went off on a tangent that I couldn’t handle.
I didn’t like it either.
No
I started it but could not finish it. Trying to decide if I will attempt it again.
No.
Did not like it at all
Did not like it.
Hated it
I liked it.
I had trouble getting involved with the narrative…I’ve tried to read it twice
It was just okay to me. I did not love it.
I’m 100 pages into it and considering letting go. Not my cup of tea and life is too short to read books you hate
How different was it compared to the movie? If it really involves a child being killed, I think I’ll avoid it. I just became a parent and it’s made those topics a little too much.
I won’t see the movie but the book does involve a child’s murder
It doesn’t show anything other than her in the after life and a few flashes of the abduction.
No.
No, you are not. I refuse to struggle to like a book, too many good ones yet to read.
Yup!
I didn’t. Not my genre, but also the writing just didn’t work for me.
I couldn’t finish it.
I hated it.
I didn’t particularly care for it although I made it through it. It’s one of the few books where I actually want to see the movie to see if it’s easier to follow/enjoy.
I just started reading this book
I guess I can understand why you might not love it but hate it??? Why? Just curious!!!
Just really struggled to get thru it, it did not hold my attention and I thought the writing was poor.
There’s a good bit of bad theology in it but I’m not a good enough Biblical scholar to explain. One of the ministers at my church led a study of it at church when the book was new but I didn’t attend. He was not a fan of it either
There was a ton of controversy when the book came out, for sure.
Nope. Me neither.
Hated it
So glad I am not alone, this book came highly recommended to me and I really struggled to finish it.
Personally, I loved it. I read it quietly, then outloud to my mom and each time I read it something new was revealed to me. Unconditional forgiveness of one’s self and others is where I go with it. I got right into it, even though the beginning was so morose.
I didn’t like it at all.
Loved it! Great message about forgiveness.
Took me starting it 3 times before I actually “got it”!
No. Found it quite manipulative
No, you are not!
I didn’t finish it. Just was not for me. DNF and moved on.
I couldn’t finish it either. Life is too short to try to finish books I don’t like. ?
Totally true. I used to try and struggle through to the bitter end….but now I just move on to another book. I don’t like wasting what little reading time I have on things I’m not enjoying.
@Juli Exactly! I used to try to finish but I feel the same as you. So many books, so little time!?
Hated it.
I started it three different times and cannot get through it.
Wasn’t crazy about it, but would like to re-read it to see what I missed.
I didn’t like it either. I’ve read inspirational books that were more interesting.
Nope.
Intensely disliked it.
Nope, hated it!
Nope.
Not my cup of tea either.
Hated it
I loved it.
Me too
Hated it
Hated it
No you are not.
Nope.
Didn’t like it either. One of the few books I didn’t finish
Did not care for it.
Not alone there
I didn’t like it, either. Definitely not worth the hype.
Liked it
No. I did not like it.
I did not like it
I hated it. Tried to read it twice, but couldn’t.
I didn’t like it. I first started it when it came out and didn’t get very far so I gave up. Then I tried again when the movie came out and was forced to finish as I was on a long plane ride. I don’t recommend it…
I also started it and couldn’t get into it, but picked it up at a later date and read it! Nope…not excited about it!
??
Hated it. Too moralistic and simplistic.
Hated it!!
I started it but I couldn’t stay with it. I picked it up a couple time after that then gave up. You are not alone
I didn’t like it, never finished it and gave the book away.
i didn’t even finish it. I was sooooo bored.
I really liked the book but did not care for the movie!
I’m with you.
Hated it!!!
Super bored, but 8 was reading for a book club and didn’t want to be the one that didn’t finish it. Uggg!
I suffered through for a book club too! ?
I referred to it as a novelized constructive theology. (Yes, I graduated from seminary.) While it had some dynamic and helpful imagery I found it to be fundamentally lame. It was as if the author wanted it to ‘all turn out.’
Totally agree!
Did not like it and never even finished it!!
I did not read the book, but I did not like the movie.
As my dear departed mom would say”drug store literature at its finest!”
I did not care for it at all.
Didn’t love it either.
No…you are not alone. I tried to read it for my Bible study group and hated it…I could not finish it. It is one of the worst pieces of garbage written and his theology is completely of base. I don’t see how it is on the list.
Agree! The theology is just “off” for lack of a better word.
Wonder how it made the list of top 100!
I didn’t either!! It seemed very cheesy in my opinion.
Go Tigers! 😀
It was a disappointment to me: especially after many friends recommended and it was a selection for the book club I was in at the time.
I hated it!!
Didn’t like book but movie moved me.
Loved it!!
I loved it
It was interesting in the beginning but I don’t think I finished it.
I enjoyed it, but honestly, I enjoyed his “Eve” better.
I loved The Shack, although I can see where the writing seems “cheesy” to some…took a bit for me to get into the story too, but at some point, I was hooked. Bought Eve after that and have yet to read it. I started it and now have to restart, as it’s been a long while. Just couldn’t get into it….will give it another try soon! Did you also read Crossroads by the same author? If so, what did you think? I haven’t yet picked that one up.
@Misty – no, I’ve not read that…it even heard of it. Eve was a far, far cry from The Shack, but still a good book. I’ll have to check out the new one!!!
Did not like it at all especially since the theology was so skewed. I was surprised and disappointed it was on the list of 100 books.
Thanks for the reviews! I can take this one off of my list.
Hated it .
Had to force myself to finish it.
You absolutely are NOT the only one 😉
Started it. Didn’t enjoy, moved on….
I read it but do not remember any of it. That tells you a lot.
Hated it!
No, you are not alone
Not a fan either.
I’m about to start reading it..cover to cover so I’ll find out. I have read 57 of the 100 and believe I can do this. This novel seems like one of the group of the most controversial included in the list. I have often differed with books touted as brilliant and found those thought so so excellent reads. It’s wonderful that the book choices feature reads for everyone and not just one genre. Happy Reading…anyone else planning to read all the books?
Yes it was very controversial when it first came out. Has some very different theological ideas in it. Let us know if you like it or not!
I’m going after the ones I haven’t read in the first batch they posted with the books they are covering and weeks. I didn’t read the first two but I will catch up. I will do.
I didn’t care for it either.
I hated it!
I hated it!
Absolutely detested it. Proselytizing and propaganda.
But that’s just me. LOL
And me 😉
Loved it
I loved it. I read it during a crisis of faith and it helped walk me off the ledge. I love the idea that we build walls around God with knowledge from other people, until we no longer have a personal relationship anymore with the true God. Then the message of unconditional love and power of forgiveness to round it out. I don’t know, it was exactly what I needed at a very difficult time.
Glad it helped you.
With that said, no way is it a book that deserves to be up there with the best of the best. I don’t think it should be on this list. ?
Started it, but could not finish it!
I did not like it.
Hated it as well.
I wasn’t a fan at all.
I was not able to finish it! However, I am still wondering why I did not enjoy it because most of the people I know just loved it!!
Hated the shack
Hated it- blasphemous
I didn’t get very far into it and just couldn’t go on. Too many other books, so little time!
Didn’t like it…and certainly don’t think it belongs on the best 100 books list.
No, you are not
I didn’t like it!
I dnf’d it 80% in!
Couldn’t finish it. Was shocked it made the list, along with several others like “This Present Darkness” and the “Left Behind” series.
Think it had some good ideas, some. But it was really boring and terribly written.
Agree !!
No i started it and didn’t finish it. I couldn’t get past the first two chapters
I haven’t read, but my mom has, she didn’t care for it.
I gave it 2 stars out of 5 on goodreads when I read it.
Was not a fan either!
Hated it.
Nope.
Only read about a third. I wasn’t feeling it.
Hated it
I didn’t love it but did find it thought-provoking.
I didn’t like it either… couldn’t even finish it.
Didn’t care for it.
nope, I didn’t care for it…
I didn’t care for it.
I’m an atheist, there is a subsect of the list that I have no interest in.
Agreed. I’m a fellow atheist, and, while I don’t object to religious writings as religious writings (I love “The Consolation of Philosophy” by Boethius,”Paradise Lost” by Milton, the poetry of Gerard Manley Hopkins, “The Book of Margery Kempe”, and “Wise Blood” by O’Connor, for example), I would prefer that they be thoughtful, not cliché, and well-written. None of those are ways I would describe “The Shack”.
Similarly, not sure I would ever find the need to read the Left Behind series. Unless there’s something I’m missing.
I had a hard time with the book, but I LOVED the movie!
No I did not like it either.
This was one time that I preferred the movie…
i could not finish the Shack…
Question is why. Why did so many dislike it? I felt the same about Cold Mountain. Too much description. Think movie more interesting because, it’s just easier.
I did like Cold Mountain, book and movie; but I like books with a lot of description. Have you read any of the Howard Bahr books?
Nope
Didn’t finish it.
Nope.
No
I didn’t love it. It was ok, but it felt manipulative
I did not care for the book, either.
I didn’t love it.
Stopped reading it.
Count me in
Not at all Biblical.
No. I couldn’t finish it
No. I was not a fan!
I never finished it because I couldn’t get into it (have meant to go back and try again; maybe I will soon).
I’m not a fan either. Several friends who never read books loved it though.
Nope. Did not like it.
It was not a favorite of mine.
The book is terrible. One of the few times a movie is better.
I did not either. I could not get over a child being hurt, let alone being able to forgive
The hype far surpassed the book. I’ve read a lot of murder mysteries and this was just another one. Later I listened to the audio version and enjoyed it more, but it wasn’t a “biblical” moment.
No
No.
I did not.
Nope
You are not alone.
Did not even try. The hype turned me off.
The book was much better then the movie
Could not get through it even as an audio, which often makes it easier for me.
No
No you are not alone. I did read it but was dissapointed with it after all the hype over it. The book just didn’t do it for me.
I didn’t care for it either.
I had a hard time finishing it
I could not finish it.
You are not alone. I didn’t hate it, but just felt kind of ‘meh’ when I finished it.
I haven’t read it and really have no desire to.
So many people I know have praised this story, so I read the book and watched the movie while trying to keep an open mind. My personal opinion is it is a subpar story with problematic claims about precious realities.
Very well said @Natalie!
So relieved to find I’m not the only one who doesn’t care for this book!
I did not.
No, you’re not the only one. I stopped reading it after a couple of chapters.
I did not love The Shack. Could not understand all the fuss.
The movie was moving for its message about love and forgiveness.
Not my thing
No. You are not alone. I intensely disliked it.
i did not like it.
https://youtu.be/HZHwxIL9oYo
Nope ?
I didn’t like it and I especially didn’t like the movie.
I didn’t like it at all!
Mixed feelings did not like movie
I didn’t like it.
I didn’t love it either.
It was poorly written and I never understood why it was so popular.
Me too. It’s like Elaine when she was the only one who didn’t like the English Patient
I did not like it. I was led to believe that it was a true story. When I found out it was fiction I was very unhappy. I felt like I had been conned into reading it.
You are not alone.
I did not like it at all!
Loved it!
Nope. I didn’t like it either. Too much of a stretch to ease a pain that could never be eased,
I couldn’t finish it, I tried, turns out not my thing. Francine Rivers is more my style.
I get the premise ( an interesting story ) but it was so poorly written that I had a hard time getting past that. I did watch the movie and liked that a bit more.
I have tried watching the movie, and kinda figured out some ….. very sad
Awful, awful book. My local book club read it and out of six people, two of us felt it was written as a purely commercial venture.
I did not like it. Tried to, but no.
I did not like it
It was not my favorite
I didn’t and I didn’t even finish. I did the audiobook maybe I would feel differently if I did the physical book, but no interest in trying it.
Did not either ?
No. I didn’t enjoy it either!
I didn’t love it either.
I am so happy to read all of these comments! For years I’ve felt like the only one! (I didn’t like Redeeming Love, either…but we don’t have to go there!)
So funny, we must have similar tastes. I didn’t like Redeeming Love either when our book club read it. Everyone else was going on and on about how great it was and I was like “meh”! LOL
It’s at least a 2 member club now!???
I thought it was just me, but just a little too out there…
I did not love it either.
I didn’t love it but it totally stuck with me.
I didn’t understand it
I can’t even remember much about it, but I do remember detesting it. ?
Me neither.
You’re not the only one.
Loved it! Thought it was a beautiful story
Just “eh” to me.
no I wasnt crazy about it either
I’m glad I read the book first.
You’re not alone. I couldn’t finish it.
I did not care for it
I liked parts of it but it just became too preachy for me
Loved it!
Not a fan.
Nope.
No, I have finally realized that just because a book is a bestseller, a classic, or popular doesn’t mean I will like it or even that it is a “must” read for ME. When I didn’t like something I would wonder, am I not intellectual enough, am I not spiritual enough, is my imagination not enough, is my comprehension not enough? With gratitude I finally realized I am enough in every way that makes me enough, I simply did not like the book. Thank God for my Kindle and sample downloads. The samples eliminate the need to purchase a book only to find out I don’t care for it. Also not my cup of tea, “100 Years of Solitude.” Oh, and not on the list, but Neil Gaiman’s “American Gods.” He is an interesting guy and penned one of the best New Years wishes ever, but that book was murder for me.
Great post
Agreed. Sometime, just on principle, I refused to read a book that’s all the rave…especially if a certain talk show host/life guru makes it so.
Thank you. Living, learning, and hopefully always growing!
@Elisa, like that Oprah selection “The Story of Edgar Sawtelle.” She went on and on and on about that book. Me, not so much and I certainly would not recommend it to anyone. I didn’t like it at all. I think that is the last book from her that I bought without checking it out first or maybe the last book from her at all. Nothing against Oprah, apparently we don’t like the same types of books!
@Lucinda ? I actually loved Edgar Sawtelle! But I picked it up randomly, without having heard or seen anything about it, so maybe I had no expectations vs you expecting it to be great? I honestly did enjoy it…. something about how it’s written (can’t pinpoint what exactly) reminded me of The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn (also a favorite!).
Read it a couple of years ago. Like trudging through mud for me; quite difficult.
Trudging thru really thick mud lol
Did not just love it, but I always have trouble with this type of writing.
I didn’t care for it either!
Hated it.
Couldn’t finish it. Yuck.
Ditto. And the same for my book group
I couldn’t finish it either. I kept thinking of my daughter and what I would do if I were in his position.
No
I’ve never read it, but from what I’ve heard you are not alone.
Had potential but I found the characters especially the godly ones lacking… Just didn’t connect with it
Didn’t like it
I didn’t finish.
It was a poor piece of writing. I did not enjoy it either.
This was a book that literally it took me 2 years to finish about half of, but once I picked it back up I really enjoyed it and kept reading. What did everyone think of the movie version in comparison?
Thought it was just me. I just couldn’t get into it.
Didn’t enjoy it
Yes. ?
I loved it. Found it peaceful and reassuring
No, I did not like it either
Not a fan
I did not like it. I tend to be wary of religious-themed work, so I kept that in mind when I read it based on a request by a friend. She herself is genuine and kind in her faith, so I read it based on learning more about her. What I did was ask her what she liked about the book, and I listened. No, it did not make any positive impression on me, and I most likely will not read other similar works unless it’s for someone important to me.
I skipped the first part because I knew what happened. If you just go from the actual shack part, it’s much better.
Tried to read it, but just wasn’t my kind of book.
didn’t even finish it I hated it so much.
Can’t read “faith-based” books…
Felt like I understood it better after seeing the movie.
I felt the same. Idk why I was so lost in reading it. I want to re-read it after watching the movie to see how I feel about it.
The next book on my to read list – I haven’t seen the movie yetl
Refused to read it. Seemed too religous.
I didn’t love it, but it was a quick read for me.
No you are not!
I did not love the “Shack” or” Lonely bones” . I LOATHE books with children as victims. When I read I don’t choose to read about shootings at schools either. Reading to me is a nice escape. I just don’t enjoy reading child victim books. I can experience that tuning into the nightly news.
Agreed. Both of those books I did not finish, which is unusual for me.
A big plot trend now seems to be children who disappear and come back some time later with little or no explanation of what happened. Having my son disappear was my – and likely all parents’ – worst nightmare. My son is 20 now but I still can’t read those books.
Didn’t love it.
No!!!! I couldn’t finish it
No, I didn’t care for it. Many of my friends and even my daughter liked it but…I didn’t even keep the book.
Awful…never finished it.
Didn’t love it either.
No you’re not! Didn’t like it at all!
I disliked it immensely!
Did not like at all. Proselytizing drivel.
??
I felt the same about Angela’s Ashes
The difference is Angela’s Ashes was about the real lives of poor, struggling people; the Shack is not…
I hated it.
I didn’t either.
Didn’t love it
Didn’t care for it either. I also don’t like Love You Forever, find it creepy. Another opinion not shared by many.
I didn’t like it.
Me too!! I did not like it at all.
It was very distressing and almost put me in a suicide frame of mind.
I did not finish or veiw the movie
Very good book. Thought provoking.
I didn’t like it.
no, you are not alone.
For the first time EVER, I thought the movie was better than the book. I didn’t like the book.
What I’m noticing on these threads is that there’s no interchange of ideas. I asked a question way back and still waiting for one answer. Tendency is to make a comment to the person who posted and then not converse with anyone else. My question was why didn’t we like it? I said style, too much description; others are u comfortable with subject.
story was too thin, too many words for not enough story …. maybe I read too much philosophy in the 60s to be impressed by the current genre
Several people answered those questions : bad writing, bad or painful subject matter, sappy, too religious, prostelityzing…
Judy—I did read the whole book. At first I was into it, but then the story was too winding, repetitive, and poorly written that I was irritated with myself for sticking with it. For some reason I remember feeling peeved at the author at the end, but I can’t recall why. It’s been a couple years.
Sorry I didn’t see your question,and I’m not retired and can’t read every minute of a day
one of the very few books I have not finished
Most said didn’t like it but not why
@Kelly Not being critical, just really wanted to know. I’m retired but only read to get sleepy at night. Also, trouble seeing, so into large print. Prob More than you wanted to know.
Not everyone likes everything; sometimes it just isn’t a match!
Most of my problem with it was theological. I didn’t like the way God was portrayed as a woman.
@Judy—Most responses are to the original poster’s question—which didn’t ask for reasons. A lot of readers will recall reasons for loving a book but those they dislike may be erased from memory except for the dislike. (Unless it was for reasons burned in the brain.) I recall why I disliked it and did answer your question, but at first I just answered the OP with “No.” You’re always free to do a separate post, but most people do not read all comments.
@Judy it depressed me terribly
@Lynn Thx
@Kelly I’m not happy that it depressed you but like that you gave me an answer. ?
This thread is ridiculously long so that may be why there is little discussion
@Judy I was about 5 years ago.
My Aunt said…you’ve got to read this!!!
I checked it out from the library,and…like I said…
I took it back quickly
@Daniel so,if ya don’t like it,
Find another playground
@Kelly I was answering Judy’s question
@Daniel please accept my apologies
@Daniel Could be. If this were a poll, the book lost. Amazing that such a fuss was made about it and the writer is now so rich.
There are many writers rich off garbage
Blech…….
No hated it too!
I loved the book…the movie… not so much! It definitely caused me to “think outside the box” and get out of my comfort zone.
I have not read it…
Not even interested…
Especially after reading these comments, huh!
Same!
@Judy Indeed!
Nope. Hated it
Didn’t work for me either.
I hated it. hehehe
I couldn’t get into it either.
Hated it.
No I just was unable to hardly get into it and didn’t finish book or see movie
The movie was laughable.
I couldn’t make it through to the end. It is very rare for me to give up on a book, but I did with that one!
On my shelf waiting to be read by me.
Tried to read it after the death of a child in our family. Nope. Couldn’t do it. Probably never will.
Hated it and wondered why folks were into it.
What was wrong with it in your opinion. I have it but haven’t read it yet. Is it too sad, or boring, or not plausible?
Not enough story, too much description and let’s face it, a little too preachy. Like fantasy and want to read about finding God? Then this is it.
Nope….didn’t like….didn’t get very far
hated The Shack. Just not for me at all.
Not a favorite of mine…
Ironically my husband, our 21 year old son and I were talking about this book last night. Neither of them made it through the entire thing; I read it years ago and really enjoyed it. Just another example of how no book speaks to everyone.
No, I did not like it.
No you are not….just could not get into it and quit.
Thanks for being brave and putting that question out there!!!
ME,ME,ME….I didn’t care for the movie and didn’t like the book.
I read it but was bored!
I tried to read it a few times and just couldn’t get into it at all.
I couldn’t even get through the first chapter it was so bad.
I didn’t finish it..maybe it was hyped too much and my expectations were too high
It felt like a misrepresentation of the cover blurb. Read it in it’s entirety and never understand how anyone could like it. I don’t quit books but this is at the top of my “should have” quit list. I put it in the trash so as not to torture anyone else.
Right there with you. And I think you nailed it with the “not as advertised” problem. That’s why I was irked.
“Misrepresentation”..like a post that’s click bait.
I make myself read at least 50pages before I give up and by then I wanted to know what happened!
Good idea
Agree 50 no more than 75. There are too many good reads to try and struggle thru a book that can’t pull you in at the beginning
Didn’t agree with all
Of it. It was really worth the read though. Movies even better
Didn’t agree?
Yes, didn’t agree with all that was in the book
I think I understand. I didn’t agree with him having to forgive the man who killed his baby.
I read that book every couple months the movie was not as good as the book
Do you find it uplifting or inspiring. Haven’t read it yet.
A little of both helps me to maintain control in my life and be stronger mentally
After i the first time i had to reread it to make sure that i did read that correctly very good book when i feel stuck or lost i grab the shack have a great read
I did not even finish it. I can only say that about 2 books – and that was one.
Same here. The first one for me was Little Alters Everywhere.
I struggled through it.
No
I couldn’t even finish it,,,,
I couldn’t finish it.
I found it more than a little schmaltzy.
Couldn’t stand it.
Couldn’t read it – just couldn’t!
All i could say after reading it was “huh??”
Could not stand it. Read about 2/3 before quitting, and only read that much because a friend gave it to with a cheerful recommendation. She encouraged me to pass it on to another friend. I think I just gave it to the library.
Saying I did not love it is nice….
I didn’t like it, either
No, you are not.
I didn’t like it either
Nope. I’m right with you! Didn’t like it at all.
You are not the only one! Hated it!
Nope
Didn’t like it at all…..
No- it went kind of “out there” for me. And I am a born again Christian. It was just “huh?” Lol.
I could not finish it.
I wasn’t crazy about it.
Didn’t finish it. Badly written
I didn’t like it either